Oh man... Pacquiao by ABSOLUTE murder. If not murder then Donaire becomes permanently disabled Gman style.
Probably Donaire.. I mean Pac was 20 at the time and pretty green at the time.. I mean Susakul had a good points lead over Pac before he got KO'd.. I think Donaire might have been able to cruise to a comfortable UD... Cant be sure though.. Lol at the fact that Donaire is actually the "bigger" than the dude who just fought at junior middleweight.. how the hell did he ever make Fly or Super Flyweight for that matter?
donaire more boxing skills and better foundation. pac at fly weight was talented and a diamond in the rough but not much boxing skills. just relied on his god given speed and power.
Nonito is already a skilled fighter at 112, Pacquiao was a crude slugger and more likely to be outboxed but he has a puncher's chance especially coz he has speed with which to catch Nonito. In the lower weights though, Pac had one-punch power and very unpredictable. But i vote Nonito by UD, would also not rule out a TKO win
Donaire Probably win if he can stay away from Pac's left. Donaire was P4P top 10 Flyweight. Pac was a 19 yr old & very raw Flyweight.
At 112, Pac was a very dangerous, but easily beatable opponent. Donaire should be able to cruise to a comfortable decision or possible stoppage. If he isnt careful or properly prepared though, he could very well end up like Sasakul.
Donaire would probably outbox and outskill Pac at this weight...could probably stop him too as he's a pretty hard puncher himself. He'd have to stay focused though or else he might find himself on his back if he has a mental lapse.