How do you think a fight with the young 130 pound Oscar vs the crude younger version of Manny at 130, say the one that drew Marquez. How do you think that Manny would fair against a young 130 pound Floyd.
Pacquiao probably beats any version of Oscar, though prime Oscar would be very close, nearly a tossup. Stylistically i just think he would always reap havoc on Oscar's fencing style, particularly with his superior footspeed. Oscar's best bet would be sticking and moving but i think he would always be drawn into fighting the wrong fight against the smaller Pacquiao. At 130 Floyd beats Pacquiao in a convincing decision win.
Manny drew with Marquez at 126 not 130. 135 is a better weight to compare for Oscar. Oscar really didn't do much at 130. I'd say the Pac that fought Diaz and Hatton beats Oscar that fought Genaro Hernandez and Jesse James Leija as well as Floyd that fought Castillo twice. I'd also tip the Pacquiao from Larios and Morales III to beat Floyd from Corrales and Hernandez fights.
oscar used his speed, height, and power in full effect in his prime. he was not a good in fighter, but neither is manny or floyd. it would just depend what kind of fight it was. oscar would be a larger, stronger version of an erik morales without the explosive right hand, but with a powerful left hand that matches manny's. late 90's version of oscar easily, easily at least draws with today's manny or floyd. and i'm not even an oscar fan. manny for all his speed as well as floyd could not drop or ko past prime oscar. sure, maybe he was not shot, but no way was he competitive on the elite stage anymore. his fight with forbes proved that. the late 90's-2001 oscar was the best version. i don't like to compare, just think of it manny and floyd the best of their eras and oscar was one of the best in his.
Floyd kills 130 pound pac, and floyd losing 2 morales at any weight class and at any point is asinine,
prime dlh would have been too much for pac and he probably gets koed. and a younger version mayweather isnt a whole lot different from this version. and imo any version of mayweather beats pac.
Are u serious atschMayweather at 130 was a harder puncher, faster, and more aggressive and offensive minded. How many fights have u seen Mayweather @ 130? Probably none with that answer :-(
