Did Machen ever get a chance to win it? My point is you asked this. "didn’t Marciano make a career out of knocking out 195lb slick defensive counterpunchers like Machen?" And the answer is an emphatic no he didn't! He only met one fighter who fits that description and he was 38 having his last 2 fights. I'm not saying Machen beats him ,I'm saying he was a 26 years old slick defensive counterpuncher as opposed to a 38years old one .A 26 years old one who , unlike 12 years older Walcott , was bang in his prime. After being caught cold by Ingo Machen went on to beat among others; DeJohn London Jones Rischer Draw with Williams A Johnson Quarry After being beat by Marciano Walcott bought a restaurant.
Rocky24th fights stops DeJohn in 10rds,gets dropped in the 2nd. Rocky 26 fights beats Valdes by decision no knockdowns. Rocky Rocky 30th fight ko's Harris in 8rds. Rocky 31 fights , decisions Folley. Rocky 32 fights, split decisions Machen. Rocky 35th fight stops Patterson in8rds. Rocky 36th fight stops Patterson in 6 rds. Rocky 37th fight is tko'd by Ali in 8rds. Rocky 39th fight is tko'd by Ali in 6rds. Nine fights 7 wins. 2 losses.
Archie Moore and Ezzard Charles qualify as slick counter punchers Archie Moore was 45-1 coming into the Marciano fight and went 28-3 afterward and reigned for another 6 years as champion. Archie Moore won his title eliminator (vs Valdes) while Machen failed to win his title eliminator (Folley). There is no doubt archie was a better heavyweight contender than Machen
Neither was a prime 26 years old and neither was 195lbs. Moore got his shot and failed, we don't know how Machen would have done in a rematch with Ingo who refused to honour one, ,or a title shot with Floyd 45-1? Yes and 28 of them were light heavies or super middles Six of the heavies had the following records 21-19-7 25-23-1 5-0-0 8-3-2 13-17-1 22-10-0 Not too difficult to run up a winning streak against that type of quality imo . Machen beat. Mederos Holman Summerlin Maximx2 Baker Jackson Young Jack Johnson Besmanoff McMurtry Hunter A Johnson Bethea Miteff DeJohn London Jones Rischer And drew with Williams and Folley. Moore beat Lavorante Rademacher Besmanoff Rischer Dunlap Valdes x2 Henry Slade Bivins Drew with Sys I've tried to focus on guys that weighed in as bona fide heavies when they fought both. I don't think there is much in it as far as resume is concerned.
81-3 Harry Mathews? Matthews was highly enough thought of to be rated by The Ring above Robinson as the #1 all-around fighter for 1951. Mathews had not lost since 1943! Rocky demolished him.
When did Mathews weigh 195lbs?lol Yes Rocky demolished him .All 179lbs of him!lol And 19 of those were actually heavyweights! lol The rest were lightweights, welters, middles ,super middles, and 15 were lhvys. NB The Ring 1951 Fighter Of The Year. RAY ROBINSON !!!!!
And that would be based on which particular Williams result at world level? correct me if I am wrong, but I do believe Rocky is a level above Billy Daniels and Alex miteff.
I don't know why you can't grasp that both men, Liston and Marciano must fight his opposites opponents at the same time they did? Liston beat Machen in his 31st fight.In his 31st fight Marciano was fighting 8-8-1 Keene Simmons!
Johnson beat; Valdes Charles Mederos Slade Peaks Whitehurst Godoy Henry Moore Satterfield Gilliam Bivins His resume shits all over Mathews'! Stop embarrassing yourself FFS! One of my dogs could make a better argument than you are capable of!
The point I’m making is why dismiss them on the grounds of weight. if 179 rules out someone being slick on the grounds of being too small, what was Machen doing losing to Johnson?
It doesn’t matter who was “prime”. What matters is who was better? Unequivocally the 1955 version of Archie Moore was better than any version of Eddie Machen moore “earned” his shot by winning his title eliminator Machen was unable to win in a title eliminator since when did getting splattered in 1 round by Johansson give Machen a right to demand a rematch? Machen got a rematch vs Folley and lost! 45-1 Moore defeated #1 ranked 6’3 215lb nino valdes 2x #5 ranked 6’2 210lb Bob Baker by knockout #3 ranked Clarence Henry Harold Johnson 4 times once by knockout (Harold Johnson beat Machen) he emphatically cleaned out the heavyweight divisons best contenders To rightfully earn a title shot vs marciano Machen didn’t do anything close to that
What win at world level did Foreman have going into his fight with Frazier? Ali against Liston? Unfortunately for you fights aren't fought on paper. Williams has about 30 pounds or so on Marciano, a half foot, a HUGE power advantage, a HUGE speed advantage, a reach advantage, and is even a better boxer. Fair enough. Williams is multiple levels above Ted Lowry if you want to play that game.