Barrera is the safer pick, but truthfully, I'm going with McGugian. Mcguigan has been matched with Arguello and Sanchez lately, two matchups where he has no chance. But Barrera wasn't nearly as good as those guys. MAB was good at just about everything, but exceptional at nothing. He doesn't have the power to wack McGugian out, and he doesn't have the speed and footwork to dance around him. I think itd be a close fight, but i have a hunch McGugian would prove too strong down the stretch.