Two hard-hitting sluggers without much in the way of technique. This would be a war. Who wins this one?
Did Maidana have those dimension at 140 though. He added wrinkles at 147 and found ways to land his looping shots with his unorthodox nature. At 140 he was a crude game slugger
I think he'd have scouted Bailey well, who indeed had no dimensions at all. He was like a poor man's Joe Smith in a lower weight class. But I take your point that Maidana did diversify his attack as he progressed.
Yeah, I would favor Maidana to get Bailey late because Bailey relied too much on finding the right hand, but there's a real possibility Bailey ends him with it. Randall was a huge puncher. Certainly one of the biggest I've ever seen at 140.