Margaritos Win Over Cotto is Bigger Than Floyd Mayweathers Biggest Single Win?

Hernandez is an ATG at 130 with many title defenses. An underrated win.

I say that Margarito's win over Cotto is at the same level, or better, than Mayweather's wins. Mayweather, in overall accomplishments, obviously crushed Margarito.

 

Yes its a better win than anything Mayweather has mustered.

 

It doesn't rank better period. When has Cotto ever fought for a belt that he didn't have handed to him. Cotto is a good boxer with solid skills but like I said before he never beat a champ of any division and never out right won a belt. You can't say the same for Hatton, JLC or Chico who beat the man in their division. Chico was rated on the P4P lists a KO artist and was favored over him. IMO JLC and Chico are cleary better fighters than Cotto with only Hatton being in question.

 

I dont know alot of people would probally take Hatton to beat Cotto.

I think its crazy that people are comparing Floyds Resume to Margaritos

Hatton
Dela Hoya
Baldomir
Zab Judah
Sharmba Mitchell
Gatti
Corley
Castillo x 2
Hernandez
Chavez
Corrales

All good or great fighters

Compare this to Margaritos, bearing in mind Margaritos had more fights than Floyd

Cotto
Cintron x 2
Clottey

 

:hey I always find it amusing when somebody goes into a Mayweather Jr discussion with Floyd as there avatar.

I think Cotto is a better fighter than anybody Floyd has ever faced, and will prove it when he bounces back.

 

Corrales

Compare this to Margaritos, bearing in mind Margaritos had more fights than Floyd

Cotto

I don't know, I'm kind of leading towards Margarito.

 

Hatton at 147, come on man don't give us that ****. How on earth is that even debateable? A guy that went life and death previously with Luis Collazo as an indication to his ability at welter is supposed to be in some way comparable to a guy that beat Mosley/Judah/Quintana?

Undermines the post completely.

 

I wanted to say Corrales was but damn I couldn't remember. Good notice. :good

 

the official rating is way better than your one.Ricky was ranked number 3

 

I don't think he'll have the career of a Oscar or even G.Hernandez two legitmate ATGs. I'm sorry Margo's win while impressive is definitely not better than any win on PBF's resume and it's ridiculous to even suggest it.

 

People are forgetting just how spectacular Cotto looked in the first six rounds of the fight. He looked like the best fighter in the world countering off of the ropes, and landing flush on Margarito almost at will. But when your opponent is a terminator, you'll eventually get broken down. Cotto looked fantastic in there, and that's why the win is even more impressive. He beat Cotto's A game.