Mayweather against these ATGs:

He beats everyone but Whitaker - but it's just my opinion.

 

Mayweather UD Arguello

Pryor TKO 11 Mayweather

Whitaker UD Mayweather

Going to be razor thin, but Mayweather UD Tszyu

Mayweather TKO 8 Morales

Mayweather TKO 5 Barrera

Mayweather TKO 4 JMM

Mayweather UD Stevie Johnston

Mayweather UD Camacho

Chavez TKO 10 Mayweather

....

In my opinion.:good

 

I think he loses to Pryor and Whitaker.

 

Arguello at 130 Floyd UD 12 2/3 times other wise Arguello TKO /Arguello late TKO15 2/3 times otherwise Mayweather UD

Pryor at 140 Pryor UD

Whitaker at 135 Mayweather UD 6/10 times

Tszyu at 140 Tszyu KO

Morales at 130 Mayweather UD

Barrera at 130 Mayweather KO

Pacquaio at 130 Mayweather KO

JMM at 130 Mayweather KO

Stevie Johnston at 135 Mayweather UD

Camacho at 135 Camacho UD 2/3 times other time Mayweather UD

Chavez at 140 Chavez late TKO

 

Whitaker clear UD.

Pryor and Chavez tko wins.

50/50 against arguello

He beats everyone else

 

I'd make Chavez, Whitaker, and Camacho slight favorites over him. Camacho was probably better @ 130, in fact the same goes for Mayweather. I think Pryor @ 140 is a more solid favorite over Mayweather than the rest, although I think Pryor is overrated historically.

The rest, I would make Mayweather the favorite.

 

Castillo is very competitive with Floyd in 2 fights but Chavez is just a slight favourite? Chavez is a 'super Castillo', I think he'd be just as much a favourite as Pryor is.

 

That is the best description of a fighter I have heard in a long time!!

 

Mayweather UD12 Arguello

Pryor TKO7 Mayweather

Whitaker UD12 Mayweather

Mayweather UD12 Tszyu

Mayweather UD12 Morales

Mayweather UD12 Barrera

Mayweather UD12 Pacquiao

Mayweather UD12 Marquez

Mayweather UD12 Johnston

Mayweather UD12 Camacho

Chavez UD12 Mayweather

 

Arguello at 130 - Floyd UD
Pryor at 140 - Floyd UD
Whitaker at 135 - Sweet Pea SD
Tszyu at 140 - Floyd UD
Morales at 130 - FLoyd UD
Barrera at 130 - Floyd UD
Pacquaio at 130 - Pac by KO..........seriously floyd by UD
JMM at 130 - Floyd UD
Stevie Johnston at 135 - Floyd UD
Camacho at 135 - Floyd UD
Chavez at 140 - FLoyd UD

 

Chavez is not as big and heavy as Castillo. Castillo's size and 9 pound advantage definitely helped make it a tougher fight for Mayweather. Up close, he was able to use this advantage. Chavez wasn't huge for his weight class like Castillo was.

Furthermore, when you have great fighters, which Chavez and Mayweather are, I tend to think the fights are usually competitive and rarely make one guy a big favorite over the other.