Mayweather Jr vs Trinidad Resume

DLH was in his prime. Trinidad won there. David Reid was also a stellar boxer and Trinidad beat him too.

 

PBF has the better resume you get no credit for fighting top opposition and losing if that's the case Zab would be an ATG.

 

Yep.

Edit: You can call Trinidad fearless, but at the same time he lost big time twice.

 

Exactly he was schooled badly against Winky and Hopkins PBF would never get a boxing lesson like that by anyone.

 

By the same token don't get extra credit for wins against average competition!

The problem here seems to be a clear misunderstanding of the word "resume"!

 

Average my ass. Who's average? Tito's wins are average IMO with the exception Oscar.

 

His daddy Mayweather Sr. claims he can still whoop his son !

 

I'll be willing to give Floyd credit for his wins over a past-prime DLH and an Hatton who had no business at 147:deal

Now I'll go down the list of his individual victories and you stop me when I get to what you consider a "great" victory:

Baldomir-average
Judah-average
Mitchell-average
Gatti-average
Brusseles-average
Corley-average
N'due-average
Sosa-average
Castillo-semi-great
Castillo-loss(IMO)

 

You forgot Corrales. Other than that I agree with your assesment.

 

I was setting up a trap, hoping he would bring up Corrales, so I could remind him that that fight took place over 7 years ago:hey

 

Trinidads resume is far better

 

so was trinidads best win.

 

Agree!