Mayweather & Pacman's wins at 147....BEST WIN?

This changes all the time for me slightly, but this is how I have it at this moment, I guess.

Pac over Cotto
Mayweather over Hatton
Mayweather over Marquez
Mayweather over Mosley
Pac over Mosley
Mayweather over Baldomir
Mayweather over Ortiz
Pac over Clottey
Mayweather over Judah
Pac over de la Hoya
Mayweather over Mitchell
Pac over Marquez III (since I scored it against him, it goes here I suppose)

-Antonio Margarito was at the 150 catch weight, so it doesn't count.

-Pac vs. JMM III was at a catchweight within the WW limit. However, the nature of the decision leads me to not exactly view it as a win.

 

I dont credit Floyd for the Marquez fight he convinced Marquez to take the fight based on the idea of a 145 pound catchweight, Floyd blatantly refused to try and take off the weight sure Marquez got paid but that isnt the point the point is those 2 pounds would have taken something out of Floyd evened up the playing field a bit.
So to Credit Floyd for that I just cant see how anybody with an objective mind would

 

Catch weight of: 144 pounds
Mayweather: 146 pounds
Marquez: 142 pounds

Marquez has more than proved his worth at fighting at the weight of 142-143. Fights can get better in retrospect. Did Mayweather pull a ***** move? 100%. Would it be a better victory if he weighed in at 144 pounds? Yes. But you're joking yourself if you don't rate the win as a very good one, if not great.

 

Pac's destruction of Cotto is by far the best win.


Mosley was a dead man by the time Floyd finally fought him.

Floyd - Marquez was a joke. Marquez had never fought at 147 before, and was pulled up two weight divisions, and Floyd didn't even meet the agreed upon catchweight.

 

:deal

 

Best wins at Welterweight in recent years....
1- Pacquiao TKO12 Cotto
2- Marquez KO6 Pacquiao
3- Mayweather UD12 Mosley
4- Mayweather KO10 Hatton
5- Mayweather UD12 Marquez

 

Floyd vs Hatton was the best win IMO

Marquez KOing Pacquaio....PRICELESS

 

I'd move Pac-Clottey up (underrated win)

Move Pac-Mosley down

Remove Pac-Marquez III

Insert Pac-Bradley somewhere near Floyd-Mosley

Otherwise pretty solid. Though I think Margarito should count as a 147 bout because normally they would have demanded it there (Margarito was a career WW but had since gained weight during suspension so they chose to accomodate at a catchweight for a bs belt) plus pac essentially fought that bout as a WW anyway

 

Mayweather was never the underdog at 147 and has the same dimensions as everyone else in the weight class. Pacquiao is the the smaller man who was good enough to compete in a division he doesn't belong in and was the underdog in many of those fights. I think Pac - Cotto would stand as Pac's best performance at the weight. Though Mosley was past his prime I think that was the best I had seen Mayweather at the weight.

 

Mayweather's wins over undefeated Hatton and #2 p4p trumph Pacquiao's win over Cotto at a catchweight

 

Oh you mean a bloated hatton who struggled his last outing at the weight and an overtrained mosley? gotcha

 

So if he did make the weight you couldnt give jmm full credit if he did win.