Here is my question: If Mayweather were to fight all of Pacquiao's opponents in his resume, who will be the hardest? and If Pacquiao were to fight all of Mayweather's opponent in his resume, who will be the hardest?
Mayweather: Hmm... probably Singsurat just because how Young Mayweather would have been when they would have fought. Pacquiao: DLH at 154 or Castillo at 135.
Morales and Barrera at 130 are tough for anyone. These are the fighters who make anybodies resume look great. From Floyds it is probably only Corrales , I dont see any of Judah , Castillo or a prime Hatton being good enough to compete. Pacquiao clearly has the better resume , but I think Floyd is the better fighter.
We did thread like this before, but I'll break it down. Floyd goes undefeated still with Erik Morales and Barrera being the hardest fights at 130. Cotto would have been somewhat tough, but Floyd outclasses him. Pacquiao loses to Oscar De La Hoya at 154 and has tough fights against Genaro because of his legnth and style Castillo in a war that Pacquiao would win Judah would have some early success vs Pacquiao because of his style and speed The only one I see him losing for sure is Oscar.
Style wise, prime Pac wins against prime DLH and have problems with prime Mosley Same way that prime Floyd wins against prime Mosley and have problems with prime DLH. But Optimus Prime wins against them all.
Ball , we havent spoken in a while , but come on Floyd went on holiday for two years so that he didnt have to face the likes of Cotto and Margarito. Give Floyd credit for being undefeated , but he simply hasnt faced the same level of competition as Manny. Floyd at 28 and in his prime fought Henry Brussels. Manny was fighting Morales.
FMJ - the 3 Mexican greats, all has great combinations, counterpunching and ring IQ, all relentless. Pac - I really can't even say ODLH, Pac schooled him so bad, but at 154, then yeah, that would be the toughest for Pac.
fmj - the 3 mexicans, cotto, margo pacquiao - dlh because its at 154. and maybe judah.. also possibly castillo.. but then again pac kd the 3 mex and they are all greater than castillo.. i just dont see castillo surviving
Oscar would do better than in 2008 but he would still lose the fight eventually, pac has a huge speed advantage and proved he could take a punch at 140+ I think he ud's Oscar at 154 116-112 type. Maybe the version that destroyed vargas, I could see that.