Mayweather would have beaten a prime ODLH and Trinidad at 147

He would have beaten Trinidad.

I think Mayweather-Prime De La Hoya is a toss up.
De La Hoya would be very clinical. He wouldn't get hit as much either. I think Mayweather would 'lose' but not really lose (compubox). Prime De La Hoya would probably give off the impression that he won, thus a 116-112 UD win for De La Hoya...
or else another SD win for Mayweather.

 

so you are saying prime DLH would not perform better than the ancient one?

 

Oscar's style could ve been all wrong for FLoyd..

I think he would ve beatin Tito easily..

With that being said, he would ve ducked both.

 

trinidad kos him or gets frustrated and loses UD, either way, wouldnt be a easy night for floyd, because tito was physicly a big strong man with long reach.

 

I actually think the ODH-Floyd would be most of the time a Floyd UD, and a Trinidad Fight would be a toss up; will he finish off Floyd with his power, or will the fustration catch up first? Trinidad had boxing skills, watch his earlier fights before he fell in love with his power.

 

Trinidad at 147 would be the easier fight.
I think floyd would take a SD from prime Oscar at 147.

 

I think it'll always be a pretty subjective fight.

 

He should beat Tito.

Old Oscar lost an 8-4 type fight with a prime Floyd. It makes sense a prime Oscar does better. It's gonna be a toss up either way and I'm not 100% sure who I'd favour.

I'm gonna say Floyd by even closer decision 7-5 type.

 

Tough fight.

 

Im not sure, Tito always had problems with boxers (but with size advantages or long reaches) and with Hoya, i don't know but i do think prime mosley had a good chance of beating May, more than those two

 

Young Mosley a iron chin and dynamite in his hands would be kryptonite for Mayweather. I agree with PR Boxing.

I think prime Vernon Forest would beat Floyd in a wide UD.

 

Different era of WW's. The elite guys were also big 147lbs. Quartey is also an intresting matchup.

I think Mayweather has the craft to beat Trinidad, and as is the concensus, splits most of the rounds with DLH, who would probably tire late and give Floyd the final 2/3 rounds for the win.

 

ODLH would beat Mayweather but we all know Mayweather would not get in the ring with ODLH.

After all "We aint fighting to see who the best is..." -Floyd Mayweather Jr.

 

i would favor floyd vs trinidad. tito could be outboxed and floyd is a great boxer. titos only chance would be to catch floyd in an exchange, something floyd would avoid at all costs. 5 rounds to 7 for a floyd win, tito would be given some rds on pure agression and making the fight.
i would favor dlh in a clear decision vs floyd. dlh is also a great boxer and when he still had legs he could keep on top of anybody with less power than him. the oscar before trinidad was much more mobile and could trouble other great boxers much more than the oscar post trinidad.