ok before we begin, we know carbajal was a LIGHT FLYWEIGHT all his career, how he would do against vic @ super flyweight?
Likely gets the **** beaten out of him...Vic is still huge at superfly. Id rate his chances better at 112.
Vic would beat him. Carbajal's style would fit perfectly into Vics brawling style, and the guy can punch really hard.
I would pick Lopez. It would be like watching Alvarez Lopez, but Vic doesnt have the chin that Alvarez had. It takes a boxer that can throw straight punches down the middle to beat Vic. Look at Donaire, a fairly good boxer, not great, and he easily took Vic apart.
Carbajal would kill him at 112 in a Donaire fashion. Fugetabout Finito. Vic would get schooled and humiliated.
I don't really rate Vic, but it woudl be really hard for Lopez and Carbajal to overcome the size disadvantages here considering their styles.