I remember the first time I saw him fight. He was different, and it didnt look like he should be effective but he was. That is why I don't take the "eye test" opinions of too many people too seriously; a fighter may not look good but still be very effective.
I enjoyed the Bounty Hunter, and saw many of his fights as they occurred. He was better than his son. But, he was never an elite fighter. More of a gatekeeper/spoiler type. A little short on skill, but, plenty of guts and toughness.