Miguel Cotto is an awesome fighter. IMO probably the best win of Pac's career. People forget the time when Miguel Cotto pretty much singlehandedly cleaned up 140 lbs when it was one of the deepest divisions...maybe ever.
Wait a minute, when the hell did Cotto clean up 140? He never fought, Tszyu, Gatti, Hatton, Harris, or Mayweather. He never unified at 140, he never even beat a reigning champ at 140.
Yeah.. I have no idea what that bull**** is all about! He has never even tried to unify any division. And he has never beaten a reigning champ.
By the time Cotto was on top, Hatton beat Tszyu, PBF beat Gatti, and Harris was blown out by Maussa. He didn't get to fight Hatton or PBF, that's true. Who he did fight, however, is (although some of these were at 147 but guys who moved up): Torres Bailey Abdullaev Branco Corley Pinto Maussa Judah Malignaggi N'dou A lot of these guys went on to win titles after getting their ass whooped by Cotto, and all of them were very good fighters in a very deep division. While guys like Gatti were picking on lightweights and PBF was fighting tuneups, Cotto was kicking serious ass in the division.
These are all B/C level guys. I can't even believe you mentioned Maussa and Abdullaev. Corley was a gatekeeper when Cotto got to him. N'Dou is basically a journeyman. Torres was a solid fighter.
The funny thing is three guys in that list Mayweather beat before Cotto got to and Cotto at the time was considered green and still rising. You need to correct something, while Cotto was fighting top notch opponents there, Mayweather failed to get Hatton(the top guy at 140 since beating Tszyu) in the ring because Hatton wanted two more fights to be ready. Then Mayweather moved up and Cotto went on to fight those "impressive" guys only to move up and fight the same guys Mayweather fought and beat, but for some reason it wasn't cherry picking and tune-up material for Cotto, it was legacy. Why didn't Cotto at least try to get Hatton at 140?
Maussa, despite his obvious laughable limitations, went on to beat Harris for the WBA title. Yes, the same Harris that the media was hyping as the most feared man on the planet at the time.