Ill go with Eddie,Mctigue ,by all accounts was a negative safety first kind of fighter who benefited from the no decision era,he lacked power ,but had some skills,Muhammad,who I remember as a very good middle then called Eddie Flame Gregory,had skills and power,he wins this by dec.
mike mctigue lost to a welterweight, and on film eddie looks very talented. Especially in his beatdown against marvin johnson. I would have to go with eddie for sure.
