Mike Tyson in his prime vs Lennox Lewis and Evander Holyfield

He has Holyfield beat in the power, chin and experience department. Holyfield though has him beat in the style, willpower and tactics department. Despite that, I would predict a a solid victory for Tyson, probably KO by the mid-rounds with emphasis being on body punching to sow down Holyfields better speed/momentum. Its say to say nobody ever got in Mikes head like Holyfield did, but at the same time 90-92 Tyson shows he could adapt to fight tactically against threads such as Ruddock instead of, say, winging it like with Tillman and Stewart.

This all assumes Holyfield doesn't get into Mikes head though. If he does then Holyfield would likely beat him.

 

It is at this time that I again remind everyone about "Evan Fields." Of Course Tyson would have won--he was a better fighter. Evander's heavyweight success came primarily from using HGH, one of the most potent PEDs, at a time when there was no testing.

Lennox--that's harder to call.

 

Most likely result against Holyfield - Tyson loses.

Most likely result against Lewis - Tyson loses.

 

A near prime Mike Tyson lost to Holyfield twice over. Holyfield bullied Tyson in both those fights and would beat the prime version as well.

A prime Lewis beats a prime Tyson as well.

Mike Tyson gets overrated based on a collection of highlight reel knock outs.

 

I'm not quite sure if you mean prime for prime or if Tyson fought both of them in the early 90s before prison? Because the dynamic changes for each of them.
'91 I'd pick Mike to beat both a green Lewis and an unestablished at the weight Holyfield - even after the Douglas loss.
Prime for prime I would choose Tyson over Holyfield (in a tough fight) and Lewis over Tyson.

 

This is Tyson with defence in his game.

 

Holyfield beats Tyson in his prime, Lennox Lewis is a toss-up.

 

Absolute best version of all there men when they meet....

Lennox beats both Mike and Evander.

And Mike beats Evander.

 

Prime Iron Mike was the best Heavyweight I ever saw. Anyone who fought him in his prime got hit on the chin hard & often. What happens to Lennox when that happens? It reportedly did happen in a sparring session when they were both up and comers. I asked Mike Tyson about that once and his response was "I was the best at that age". I interpreted his response as meaning "I beat the crap out of him".

Outside of his prime (post 1988), both Lennox & Evander have too much for Mike Tyson. Post 1988, Iron Mike couldn't put together 12 hard rounds. That would be needed to finish in front of Evander.

 

Tyson is younger than Lewis and Holyfield. Yes he became champ first and went to prison but this question has always felt like Tyson fans looking for a route to elevate him above guys who beat him. Typically when the "would loser beat winner in their prime" question is asked the loser of said fight is older and signifigantly older.

Tysons dominance was because he wasn't fighting the best fighters of his era. That was not Tysons fault and you can only beat the fighters the ABCs put in front of you but when this wasn't the case that dominance wasn't there. And that was true at all stages of his career whether it be Tucker, Buster, Ruddock, Holyfield or Lewis. And yes I'm saying in hindsight Tucker and Buster were better than Holmes and Spinks at least when Tyson fought them. On the flipside Tyson destroyed lesser fighters in the 80s and 90s and even the early 00s very consistantly.

 

Man I just wish Holyfield-Tyson would have happened in '91.

 

Holyfield beat him when he was in his “prime”

he might’ve been a little past his prime when Lennox beat him, but not that far past it


I think you’re taken away from the skills of Lewis and Holyfield when you say they had to face a “ past his prime” Tyson

Tyson was not that old, and he was in fantastic condition…. stop making excuses


“Prime” Tyson was thoroughly beaten by Douglas, Holyfield, and Lewis


You need to come with the grips with the fact they were just better fighter than Tyson. Period

Tyson seemed so invincible because no other fighters on the world level were there in the early to mid 80s.. and when they started showing up, he started getting beaten

 

IMO 1988 Mike Tyson would beat 1992-93 Holyfield.
1988 Mike Tyson Vs. 2000 Lewis is more complicated and requires a separate topic; 55 percent I think the 2000 Lewis would win in that fight.