Well you'd obviously have to favour Garcia but I'd certainly pick this Luke over any LW Garcia has beaten.. Luke will come again & pick up a decent win no doubt
Why would you have to favour Garcia? His best win is still a smaller Salido, and the only time he fought a well schooled southpaw who utilises range, he lost every second. I would bet the house on Campbell beating Garcia (in the imaginary world where Garcia took on a challenge in his weight division).
Errol has one inch more in height and reach than Campbell, in terms of skill I don’t think there is anything to separate them. I think Mikey would probably open up more against Campbell, and get taken out. So yeah, it’s not an exact comparison.
Based on...? Getting dropped by Martinez? Losing every second against Spence? Losing rounds against the likes of Broner? Quitting in his best win? Blatantly ducking a guy that Campbell fought, despite Campbell’s father dying two weeks earlier? I’m the idiot here? I don’t think so.
Far lesser fighters have stopped Pac with a body shot. Then you factor in that he isn’t getting hit to the body anymore because he’s the shorter man fighting taller punching bags, then you factor in Lomachenko’s vicious body punching. That’s the most likely outcome, followed by Lomachenko winning every round.
I could name literally hundreds of fighters that would have done better against Spence than Garcia did, who started at 126. Fresher versions of Floyd and Pac would beat Spence.