Modern Brit ATGs v pre-war Brit ATGs on the legacy list

Would anyone else have the Ragamuffin Man above Hatton on the post war list? and what about John conteh? Randy Turpin?

I would

 

Yeah, clearly all far better and accomplished than Ricky (you might rank Hatton over Turpin if you were really trying) but again I think these are selected fighters: Chatty has picked these names for a reason

 

Nah, Turpin>>Hatton

 

I agree.....but the modern lovers would try.

Ray>>>>>>>>Tzsyu for starters :deal

 

Ray>>>everyone to lace on gloves :yep

 

:nono








Arguably though

 

Where's Jimmy Wilde?

 

Froch is a G. He's clearly surpassed Calzaghe IMO.

 

that depends what you mean by surpassed though, surpassed him in what way, remembering that Froch has lost to Ward and Kessler, and Calaghe not only beat a prime unbeaten Kessler for the undisputed championship, but put on a masterclass

 

Froch's record is better. Fought better opposition more consistently. :rasta

 

does it count if he lost to said oppsition? including a Faded Kessler, think about that

 

Calzaghe lost to Hopkins IMO. If you add it all up Froch has a better record.

IMO

 

I'm feeling the Jackie Patterson love Flea. Wonderful little fighter who I have a soft spot for as he grew up just a few miles up the road from my gran.

From the post was Brits, I think Conteh might have been the best outside of Lennox. I'm also one of the people who rate Froch's career as better than Calzaghe's, although Joe was probably the better fighter in his prime (but being incredibly talented means **** all if you spend 8 of your best years not utilising it)