More skilled: James Toney or Dwight Muhammad Qawi

Two fighters known for their impeccable defense and terrific counter punching ability although very different styles from each other with Toney relying on his opponents to come forward while Qawi was the one who came after his opponents. I personally think they were both pretty close together in terms of skills and H2H ability but who would you say was better in both departments in your opinion?

This content is protected

This content is protected

 

Counterpunching wise I would say Toney was better. Defensively they're close to equal IMO. I would say Qawi was better at chasing his opponents down, either methodically or relentlessly while Toney seemed to look flustered whenever he was against an opponent that had good footwork.