Most Impressive Resume: Paul Williams or Antonio Margarito

Originally Posted by CarlesX7
1. Why would you have a "problem" with such questions???

2. Think about this: Let's say Floyd got beat on points by another fighter, making him 39-1.
Let's say the other fighter was undefeated with a 30-0 record, but his wins prior to Floyd were somewhat "gobbage" as you said.
So that would make his win over Floyd by far his most notable one.
Having in mind Floyd's resume, would you honestly say that the other fighter is better than PBF, just cause he beat him once?

Alright man since you are being persistent lol. Did you think Rahman was better than Lewis after he beat Lewis? Did you feel Forrest was better than Shane after he beat Shane the first time? Two scenarios...and this is why I said your question was irrelevant, but I'll answer anyway. Personally, I wouldn't say the other guys is better than Floyd, but I wouldn't say Floyd is better than the guy who out pointed him, and I don't care how many men in Gorillia suits Floyd has on his resume. At this point I do believe Williams is better than AM.

 

About the ranking question, I've answered that and presented my argument in the proper thread


Where is your argument on thr ranking question? I need to read it again. Tell me what number post it was, or repost it for me...thanks

 

Alright, you seem to think H2H is more important than I do.

Fair enough, although I disagree

I would still think Floyd is better, except if the other guy went on and beat more elite fighters, proving himself.

[url]http://www.eastsideboxing.com/forum/showthread.php?t=92548&page=3[/url]

it's #32

 

No, Head to head is a case by case scenario. Yeah, I thought Roy Jones was better than Montell Griffith, Lewis was better than Rahman, and Williams was better than AM. No, I didn't think Quintana was better than Williams, and no I didn't think Raf Marquez was better than Izzy Vasquez after they won. You catch my drift?

 

To tell you the truth... no!!! :?

Assuming we're talking before any rematch took place:

Rahman beat Lewis, but u still thought Lewis was better.
Quintana beat Williamas, but u still thought Williams was better.
BUT, Williams beat Margo, and u thought Williams was better!!!

Sorry, I don't get it.

 

PW because he beat AM already lolz j/k

 

atsch Just think about it...

 

Margarito, and it's not really that close.