Most numbers of atg beaten? Pac or Floyd

just about right. 5 to 3.

 

I dont consider mosley an atg and the marquez win has little meaning for floyd, the only atg he beat was Oscar and im pretty sure a few years ago everyone thought he was only a hof boxer because of his losses, yet now I even see people rank Oscar above morales and barrera.
Imo its 3-1: pac has barrera,morales,marquez vs floyds oscar.
Oscar win gets pac little to no credit despite the risk because it was at 147 and how Oscar looked.

 

jmm counts? pre-fight jmm was already ****ed in weight and we all knew it was a complete mismatch right from the outset because of this.

 

agree but it's a big IF. Cotto is HOF though.

 

Castillo is surely hall of fame worthy, maybe better.

 

We know that's not going to happen. Cottoe made the decision to never step with a Slick fighter after seeing what Bernard did to his fellow boriqua Tito. Miguel is determined to never experience the same fate.

 

Cottoe baarly a G led alone an ATG :rofl the mined of a pacturd atsch

 

off names only.

pac: mab, jmm, morales, mosley, oscar
floyd: oscar, jmm, mosley

 

Hatton?

He was lineal champion for 4 years.

 

Baldomir is the GOAT.

 

I think hatton will make the hall but he aint atg worthy IMO. he never hit top p4p spot and his resume isn't worthy enough to compensate IMO.

 

castillo I was thinking about but he's a level beneath IMO