My Current Pound-For-Pound List, as of July 2011

1. Pacquiao
2. Donaire
3. Martinez
4. W.Klitschko
5. Marquez
6. Bradley
7. V.Klitschko
8. Ward
9. Bute
10. Hopkins
11. Froch
12. John
13. Segura
14. Khan
15. Wonjongkam

 

@bailey and head

where are your lists? did you not read the post saying any debate should be met with a list?

head, i've pretty much accepted you're a troll.

bailey you sometimes make decent posts, why reduce yourself to trolling?

now put up your own lists with your own criteria or don't bother responding.

 

Until Floyd fights he shouldn't be on the list...

I have Sexy Sergio at #2

With Floyd absent from the list, you could add Froch, Khan or Hopkins to complete the 10...

Other than that, good list...

 

1st of all, shut the **** up homo, i don't take orders from anyone. this isn't even your thread, so get your head out of popkins ass or you will be deepthroating me for a month. you think i'm a troll and yet in your p4p list, you have bernard hopkins as number 5 and you claim that vladimir klitchsko is on the same level of greatness as lennox lewis :rofl

secondly, get off pops dick luf, you are a ****ing embarrassment with your deepthroating everyday. its like having floyd mayweather and leonard ellerbe on esb

thirdly, sort your vcash total out, its an absoloute disgrace :-(

fourthly, my p4p list will be up shortly anyway, though the reason i'm not so keen on doing p4p lists is because i pay **** all attention to any of the feather fisted lighter weights, so its unfair on those lil fella's when i don't recognise they're achievements properly.

 

3.Sergio Martinez
Why?: By my cards, he's on the hottest run in the sport, beating Cintron, Williams twice, Pavlik and Dzinziruk in his last five to come from nowhere to #3. Sadly, has a pathetic next fight lined up.

No way sorry but there's simply nobody good at 160lb martinez should be 9th 10th

 

1 pacquiao
2 mayweather (though its about time he was ****ed off)
3 martinez
4 donnaire
5 vladimir
6 marquez
7 froch (will raise a few eyebrows but i scored the kessler bout for froch. fantastic performance away from home in front of a partizan crowd. his winning resume (imo) of pascal, taylor, dirrell, kessler, abraham, johnson is sensational)
8 khan - (his wins over maidana and kotelnik are better than any fighter on bradleys resume imo)
9 bradley
10 cotto

 

why are people ranking martinez so high is simply beyond me ? care to explain anyone ? I think he has a weak resume

 

1. Pacquiao
2. Mayweather
3. Donaire
4. Martinez
5. Marquez
6. Ward
7. Klitschko
8. Bradley
9. Wonjongkam
10. Segura
11. Gamboa
12. Khan
13. Cotto
14. Hopkins
15. Froch

 

I think Nonito should be higher based on how he dispatched his opposition, were not talking a lot of 12 round fights here like Froch and Ward. We are talking 9 of his last 10 wins by KO and these are p4p fighters too not chumps, former titleholders and so forth. List to come soon.

 

I had pascal in my top ten before losing to hop.

So you say I deepthroat popkins and then bring up the debate I had with (and still stand by my point) popkins regarding lewis.

Now if by deepthroating you mean respect as a poster and appreciation for his threads then let me tell you this, that same criteria fits to bailey and michigan warrior. So do I deepthroat them as well?

Every so often you do a good post (like on my boxing moment thread) then you come out with **** like this?

 

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Nonito Donaire
3. Sergio Martinez
4. Juan Manuel Marquez
5. Timothy Bradley
6. Wladimir Klitchko
7. Pongsaklek Wongjonkam
8. Giovanni Segura
9. Andre Ward
10. Amir Khan

I don't rank mayweather on this list is because I removed him after a year of inactivity, this was not due to promotional issues or injuries, this was him refusing to fight. I don't care if he has a fight scheduled now, I can reassess after the fight in September. This is a CURRENT p4p list not an ATG list.

 

yes, martinez doesnt have an atg resume but the guy has started boxing late and has probably been mismanaged and avoided for years wasting his time in Spain.
Martinez did well vs bunema and beat cintron at 154 for the title but got robbed.
He then moved up to face paul williams and they had a close war, williams was p4p ranked at that time so martinez giving him hell (a lot of people thought he won) had him entering the end of the p4p, you could make a case for him being in the top 10 at that point based on his results, he was a underdog those times, also in his fight after that when he beat pavlik and became middleweight champion in 2010, then following it up by again as an underdog brutally ko'ing number 3 paul williams and becoming fighter of the year had him move from the middle rankings to the top 4, where he is basically competing with donaire for position number 2 in floyds absense.
Basically the guy is a latebloomer that stepped up in 2008 beating most from an underdog position, became the victim of boxing politics but he is the middleweight king currently.
Martinez deserves his ranking based on his recent accomplishments, skills and his dominating display.

 

Looks like the lists are fairly consistent, particularly the top 5.

Regarding Floyd; I agree he should be absent at this point in time.

However, where does he rank after Ortiz? Would a KO rank him higher than Pac? I'd probably say yes. But then it's hard to justify this when he would have fought once in 16 months.

Awkward mother****er.