My New P4P List, Top 35!

I like Miguel Cotto, but as much as his fans will say he is vindicated, the loss to Antonio Margarito happened as a result of function, which was his opponent's resilience and determination. He does not deserve a spot among the top 10 fighters in the world, and Mosley's destruction over Antonio vindicates that, I believe. Just my opinion

Israel Vasquez has been a lot more consistent than Darchinyan, and has beaten better fighters than Ivan Calderon. He is too low on your list.

I love the fact Juan Manuel Lopez makes the cut. He is in my top 10, also.

1. Juan Manuel Marquez
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Bernard Hopkins
4. Israel Vasquez
5. Ivan Calderon
6. Shane Mosley
7. Vic Darchinyan
8. Paul Williams
9. Juan Manuel Lopez
0. Ricky Hatton

 

This is the current top 35 p4p:

1. Bernard Hopkins / Manny Pacquiao
3. Juan Manuel Marquez
4. Miguel Angel Cotto
5. Shane Mosley
6. Ivan Calderon
7. Chad Dawson
8. Ricky Hatton
9. Paul Williams
10. Israel Vazquez
11. Chris John
12. Arthur Abraham
13. Vitaly Klitschko
14. Wladimir Klitschko
15. Mikkel Kessler
16. Kelly Pavlik
17. Vic Darchinyan
18. Juan Manuel Lopez
19. Rafael Marquez
20. Celestino Caballero
21. Nonito Donaire
22. Edwin Valero
23. Timothy Bradley
24. Jorge Linares
25. David Haye
26. Jermaine Taylor
27. Tomasz Adamek
28. Nate Campbell
29. Lucian Bute
30. Joan Guzman
31. Joshua Clottey
32. Roman Gonzalez
33. Andre Berto
34. Gerry Penalosa
35. James Kirkland

 

two Joe Cazlzaghe fans thinking their veiled bull**** holds ice, and they want Cotto out of the top 10? seems likw more Margo craving to me, a Vile and putrid listing I wipe my ass with both your product.

 

I don't feel Cotto, who was just destroyed by a fighter who was also just destroyed, should be listed among the best in the game. Obviously, another big win can catapult him up there right away, but as of now, I feel there are other fighters who either have more momentum, have beat better fighters, or have been winning on a more consistent basis lately. Not a big deal, just my view.

Shame you're so dismissive.

 

Adamek not high enough, Linares too high, Donaire too high, trade Williams for JuanMa and you've got a half-decent list.

 

Nobody gives two shits. :tired

 

Ill pick it apart because, thats why you posted it right? :hi:

I agree with your number 1, Bhop is the best.

I don't agree with your number 2, Since JMM lost to Pac last time.

Mosley is way too high, one big win (over an exposed cheat) does not catapult him back to top 5 p4p. Hes just outside the top 5.

Cotto is a great fighter, but he dosent belong in the top 10 IMO. WHO HAS HE BEAT? He had a very good win over mosley. but other than that his record dosent indicate top 5 p4p for me.

I dont think ricky or Juan or top 10 p4p either.

David haye should be ranked muchhh higher aswell. Other then kirkland at 35 atsch ( seriously omitting world champs like sergey but putting in james) your list seems pretty good to me :thumbsup

 

Well, someone has to say it... uh... Valero? Can't possibly be above that many guys that have fought top 10's in their division. But you probably already know that.

 

replace Marquez with Hatton and youve got a solid list.

 

And to the chap that said Cotto shouldn't be in there, his resume is deep as ****....Mosley allowed to be just outisde the top five, but Cotto, who has a win over him, as well as wins over Torres, Corley, Judah, Jennings rofl) and who has always fought decent opposition (Randall Bailey in his 20th fight for example) and will now be fighting another ABC belt holder Clottey, who is held in high regard by some.

The boxing masterclass he was putting on against Marg shows he has P4P skills, and in light of the recent evidence found on Margo shows he has P4P toughness too :good

 

Why the hell is Hopkins #1?

 

Chris Arreola shouldnt be any where near top 100 much less 35.

 

Cotto is a very good fighter, but he is still unproven. Other then mosley he has not yet fought a top opponent(barring the marg fight). You can't count the judah win since had lost to carlos baldomir and mayweather right before the fights. Hes pretty much shot. Also torres is a good win, but nothing to warrent top pound for pound status, same with paulie mag. Cotto is defintly hovering around 9-12 range though. But that is only because of the mosley win. Remember, he has NEVER properly become a champion, he has only won vacant titles (never unifying titles either). So cotto has never even been the real champ of his division....... Do you really think that warrents top 5 p4p???