My new top 10 P4P. Discuss.

i think israel vasquez should be lower, the man hasn't done **** after that 3rd fight with marquez

vic darchinyan higher than williams, he accomplish more, in fact he should be higher than mosley too

 

Here's mine

1. Pacman
2. Marquez
3. B-Hop
4. Cotto
5. Mosley
6. Calderon
7. Paul Williams
8. Darchinyan
9. Vasquez
10. Adamek

Vasquez falls out due to inactivity, Dawson fighting Tarver again doesn't put him on my list, Donaire has P4P skills but lacks the resume, Linares has fought NO ONE OF NOTE (bar a shot Larios) and Cotto moves right up due to Hatton leaving the top 10.

With a win over Marquez I'd put Floyd at no.2, but he's not going to jump back in my list due to announcing his return.

Would've included Caballero, but I think JuanMa has a good win over Penelosa that equals Caba's over Molitor, so wasn't sure where to place them.

Rafael Marquez leaves due to inactivity (I had him about four places below Vasquez as per my last list)

Dawson will jump Adamek with a meaningful win :good

 

can someone tell me why is calderon a bit high on everyones list?

 

He did get outclassed by Dawson, but dropped him, and also, you could make a point that Dawson probably should've lost to Johnson.

as I said, Cotto is that high based on people leaving the top ten rather than him moving up.

I have him ranked above Mosley due to the fact that he beat Mosley, and whilst Mosley beat Marg, you have to believe that Cotto would've carried on outboxing Toni had his face not been smashed in with plaster-fists:good

 

It was either Adamek or Haye.

And Donaire may have beaten Vic, but hasn't done much since. I think his recent win (whilst he showed some fantastic technique and his opponent was unbeaten) is being blown out of proportion.

 

Mine

1. Pacman
2. JMM
3. Hops
4. Cotto
5. Mosely
6. Williams
7. Dawson
8. Calderon
9. Darchinyan
10. Donaire

Ill put Izzy and Joy in there when I see they come back into the ring.

 

:good

And think, should he beat a weight-climbing Gonzalez or rejuvanated Viloria, he would have a 'defining' fight so to speak.

They are winnable fights for Calderon IMO, especially Viloria. Calderon is like, 34 years old???? He hasn't got long left and very well might retire undefeated.

 

how about dawson? i think he should be in somewhere

 

Hes very undersized for his division even for the division below him but he remains dominant. Probably has the best footwork in the sport today if you dont include Mayweather.

 

Very fair points, I do think Cotto won that fight.

Do you not include Pac's recent 'victory' over Marquez? If you don't include the Cotto-Mosley for both fighters, surely you wouldn't inclue Marquez-Pac 1 or 2 for both fighters???

Personally I had Marquez winning 115-112, but go with the official scorecard nonetheless.

I only go against the official card in a robbery, i.e Sweet Pea vs. Chavez :good