my p4p list off the top of my head...critique

Surely Wlad Klitschko makes top 25 lbs for lbs somewhere

 

Top 10 looks good except I would put Vazquez 8 and Rafael Marquez 9. I wouldn't put Calderon in the top 10. I didnt really look at 11 through 25. Top 10 is all that matters to me.

 

Oscar Delahoya just fought the #1 on that list to a virtual draw, he doesn't even make the top 25? Wlad has been dominating his division like no other fighter in the sport and he doesn't even make the top 25? Did you see Casaymayors last fight?

And my biggest objection....Winky Wright should not be dropped from the top 10! You don't even have him in the top 20 :rofl

 

I actually saw a dissapointed look on Millies face while she considered her future as the Queen of the Filthy Rich Empire, so she might've thought Floyd won too :yep

Winky Wright has been dominant. He ate his way up 16lbs north of his best weight and fought a guy on your top 10 P4P list atsch He was winning early on, but the weight and Hopkins **** tactics finally wore him down.

 

haye just smashed mormeck to become the champ at CW, that win is bigger than anything dawson has managed in his career.

 

He beat Taylor bozo. Stop going by boxrec and go by what you have actaully seen. The guy dominated Mosley, Dominated Tito and beat the **** out of Taylor. Embarrassed Quartey and made Soliman look drunker than he usually does. And if he drops back down to 154, where he belongs, he will school anyone that dares get in the ring with him. :good

 

1. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Joe Calzaghe
4. Juan Manuel Marquez
5. Bernard Hopkins
6. Ricky Hatton
7. Miguel Cotto
8. Israel Vasquez
9. Rafael Marquez
10. Juan Diaz

 

no he really didn't, it was an even fight. taylor was controlling from the centre of the ring but allowed himself to be pushed up against the ropes too much where winky took control. i had winky one up going into the 12th but he practically gave that round away.

the anti-taylor hysteria on here sometimes really takes the ****.

 

Hmmm.....Good list although Pavlik is in all fairness far too low. He is comfortably top 12 IMHO, he knocked out Miranda, and the p4p ranked unbeaten MW champ. Also Winky is way too low, he is top 15. Casamayor should be off that list, Santa Cruz beat him...And Jermain Taylor should feature near the bottom also. Top 10 is good, though I dont agree with Calderon. And I have Calzaghe at number 2, but I cant argue with Pac.