WTF Katsidisatsch Im not even gonna 2nd guess on that one:nono He was decisively beat by Diaz only a couple years ago. Who has he beaten since then 2 be on this list? Jesus Chavez is an old man Kevin Mitchell,Vicente Escobedo are unproven. Katsidis is my #4 lightweight Funeka,Guerrero,Soto would be on here before him. (**** maybe even the dude who whupped him Juan Diaz)
There was a time when Williams might have been overrated. But not the case anymore especially on ESB where he has become underrated. He has a better resume than almost anyone today and would either beat or be very difficult for anyone around his weight division. Has beaten Martinez(controversial) Winky Phillips Margarito Quintana And was on his way to beating up Cintron until he dived out the ring.
:rofl Judging from your Top 40 list I very much doubt it. I'll give you credit for your top two rankings, they were spot on in my opinion. The rest is all over the place though. You couldn't even put a credible top ten together, how the **** do you expect me to take the rest of your list so serious? I'm not sure I'd be that silly to try and put a top 40 together so will pass on that for now And yes you're correct, if I was silly enough to try to I'm sure you could pick it apart :good
Why would I want to do that? I quite like this place and find a good majority of the posters on here who know their stuff. Just because I don't include you, don't go getting all sensitive on me.
i think the list is ok and ill give u respect just for takling the time to do it. thats commitment to the cause!
I already have on numerous occassions you clown and they're nowhere near the spectacle this piece of shite is. I put my p4p top 10 on this thread even.
Why? The talent-pool in today's era of boxing is thread-thin, Martinez has as good a claim as anybody to a #4/5 spot. Pavlik was a very good win considering he moved up and easily beat the lineal champ, he arguably beat Williams on short-notice who was a top 10 P4P fighter in everybodies list aswell, and he's a real handful for anybody at 154/160.