My list: 1. Manny Pacquiao 2. Floyd Mayweather Jr 3. Nonito Donaire 4. Juan Manuel Marquez 5. Andre Ward 6. Sergio Martinez 7. Wladimir Klitschko 8. Vitali Klischko 9. Yuriorkis Gamboa 10. Bernard Hopkins 11. Tim Bradley 12. Miguel Cotto 13. Lucian Bute 14. Toshiaki Nishioka 15. Anselmo Moreno 16. Lamont Peterson 17. Amir Khan 18. Chad Dawson 19. Robert Guerrero 20. Chris John 21. Orlando Salido 22. Mikkel Kessler 23. Carl Froch 24. Brandon Rios 25. Roman Gonzalez 26. Jean Pascal 27. Brian Viloria 28. Abner Mares 29. Guillermo Rigondeaux 30. Celestino Caballero 31. Ricky Burns 32. Takashi Uchiyama 33. Jhonny Gonzalez 34. Yoan Pablo Hernandez 35. Tomasz Adamek 36. Devon Alexander 37. Victor Ortiz 38. Giovanni Segura 39. Paul Williams 40. Erislady Lara 41. Carlos Molina 42. Sonny Boy Jaro 43.Pongsaklek Wonjongkam 44. Andre Berto 45. Saul Alvarez 46. Joseph Agbeko 47. Nkosinathi Joyi 48. Hernan Marquez 49. Marco Huck 50. Alexander Povetkin 51. Daniel Geale 52 Kazuto Ioka 53. Miguel Vazquez 54. Humberto Soto 55. Tavoris Cloud 56. Gabriel Campillo 57. Juan Manuel Lopez 58. Marcos Maidana 59. Omar Narvaez 60. Adrien Broner 61. Koki Kameda 62. James Kirkland 63. Suriyan Sor Rungvisai 64. Jorge Arce 65. Felix Sturm 66. Matthew Macklin 67. Vic Darchinyan 68. Beibut Shumenov 69. Antonio DeMarco 70. Dmitry Pirog 71. Kelly Pavlik 72. Steve Cunningham 73. Ulises Solis 74. Zsolt Erdei 75. Poonsawat Kratingdaenggym 76. Nathan Cleverly 77. Ivan Calderon 78. Moruti Mthalane 79. Juan Carlos Salgado 80. Austin Trout 81. Victor Terrazes 82. Fernando Montiel 83. Hozumi Hasegawa 84. Lucas Matthysse 85. Viacheslav Senchenko 86. Krzysztof Wlodarczyk 87. Denis Lebedev 88. Takahiro Ao 89. Cornelius Bundrage 90. Robert Stieglitz 91. Gregorz Proska 92. Julio Cesar Chavez Jr 93. Kell Brook 94. Antonio Tarver 95. Mike Jones 96. Andy Lee 97. Shane Mosley 98. Robert Helenius 99. Tyson Fury 100. Hassan N'Dam N'Jikam Thoughts?
It is such a hard task to try and compile a top 100 list. I could pick apart ranking by ranking but I won't because I appreciate the effort. However, your top ten needs some work.
He's certainly on the rise at the minute. Looking at the top lightweights I think only Marquez, Rios and Guerrero beat him but perhaps only Rios will fight at lightweight again. I see a fight with Vazquez as pretty even but I think he beats DeMarco and Mitchell
Whichever way I have them thats always going to cause a lot of debate. Here is a crazy idea: why don't Manny and Floyd fight each other, then we know for sure who's number 1? :good
rios is 50/50 fight due to styles, RG and JMM and linares beat him in my opinion - due to styles again
I'd personally have Roman Gonzalez a bit higher myself. In regards to Lightweight, Vazquez v Burns would be a really good fight both guys are very similar, tall, rangy, boxers with little power...
Before he got blasted out by Jaro last week Wonjongkam was in the top 15 before he looks like he may of got old overnight. I'll be intrested to see his next fight against decent opposition. I agree with you that Lara and Campillo was robbed (particularly Lara) in their fights against Williams and Cloud but I decided to base it on actual results first and foremost and I believe Williams and Cloud have better resumes.
What do you have as top 10? I think 99% of people have Manny and Floyd as number 1 and 2 but in different orders 90% probably have Marquez, Martinez, Donaire and Ward as 3 to 6 in different orders. The Klitscho's will be in the vast majority of peoples lists now. The final 2 slots in the top 10 are normally between Gamboa, Bradley, Hopkins, Cotto, Bute, Nishioka and Moreno (especially following loses in the last fights of Froch, Wonjongkam and Segura).
Gonzalzez has the talent without a doubt. I'd like to see him start fighting better oppostion though before putting him in the top 20. Ulises Solis would be a good start. I actually find Vazquez a bit boring and would much rather see Burns in with MItchell or DeMarco, but I would be intrigued to see who wins.
Yeah possibly Linares. I don't consider him a top lightweight at the moment though. He needs to beat a top 10 guy.