1 - Diego Corrales v Jose Luis Castillo I 2 - Israel Vasquez v Rafael Marquez III 3 - Somsak Sithchatchawal v Mayhar Moshipour 4 - Erik Morales v Marco Antonio Barrera I 5 - Micky Ward v Arturo Gatti I 6 - Oscar De La Hoya v Fernando Vargas 7 - Erik Morales v Manny Pacquiao 8 - Manny Pacquiao v Juan Manuel Marquez I 9 - Bernard Hopkins v Felix Trinidad 10 - Marco Antonio Barrera v Erik Morales III What do ya think? I know many will feel that Hoya-Vargas shouldn't be as high, and that a fight as one-sided as Hopkins-Trinidad shouldn't be there, but I have good reasons for putting them there (which I will explain later). :hey Please point out any glaring omissions. I'm sure I've missed out a few over ten years of fight action. And, let us see your top 10's.
Barrera-Morales kinda low IMO. Was a truly great fight. Still a good effort, I don't think I could make a top 10 list of the decade, too many great fights. However, if I were to do a list, here's a fight that would be given serious consideration: Lennox-Vitali :yep
I actually had Lennox-Vitali on my shortlist. I think Corrales v Castillo I is the undisputed no.1. I picked Vasquez v Marquez III due to the amazing comeback by Vasquez over the final third of the fight. Moshipour v Sithchatchawal is interchangeable with Morales v Barrera I, but I gave it the upperhand due to the fact that the official decision in the Morales-Barrera bout left a bad taste in my mouth at the time and took a bit of the high of the fight away for me.
For some reason I would probably include Margarito-Mosley if I did a list.I just like that fight.Not because I hate Margarito either Others I'd consider Arce-Hussein 1 Mosley-Oscar 1 Cotto-Margarito Toney-Jirov Brewster-W Klitschko 1
I actually feel bad about leaving out the fight between Israel Vasquez and Jhonny Gonzalez. I feel its an underated classic. You could throw it into the top 10 and have no complaints from me.
Had those three on my shortlist. I left out Cotto-Margarito due to the question marks over the fight. I never thought of Toney-Jirov; that was a great fight.:good
Solid list.Too lazy to make a list but will mention 10 fights not in any particular order: Trinidad-Vargas Lewis-Klitschko Trinidad-Mayorga Jirov-Toney Gatti-Ward III Ward vs Augustus Cotto-Torres Arce-Concepcion Katsidis-Casamayor Katsidis-Amonsot
Was Hopkins/Trinidad that great? It was good by Hopkins standards but compared to the other choices on the list it sticks out like a sore thumb... Some nice choices there.
I just remember being exhilirated by this fight. As the commentator said at the end "what a great fight, and probably the best one-sided fights you are ever likely to see". Plus the fact that Hopkins was the underdog, but ended up putting on such a clinic. And also there was the fact that Trinidad never gave up; after he connected with a shot you thought "oh here we go, Felix will take over from here", but Bernard never let him. Trinidad was even standing at the end ready to go again, the poor guy never even realised he was done. Technically wise Hopkins was almost punch perfect that night. Plus it was a "BIG" fight, between two of the top operators in the world of boxing at the time, and it delivered for me. To be fair though I thought that Hopkins-Tarver was a classic; I have a strange taste in fights. As I said earlier, I wouldn't mind throwing Vasquez-Gonzalez in there as a replacement.
Agreed. Vaz v Gon was a crazy fight. Four knockdowns was it? That was a good undercard. Barrios v Guzman was good too but Barrera v Juarez 2 was bloody awful.