My Top 10 P4P list - what's yours?

Having Calderon that high is utterly ridiculous...who the **** has he beat?

 

1 manny pacquiao
2 Floyd Mayweather
3 Miguel Cotto
4 shane mosley
5 bernard hopkins
6 wladimir klitschko
7 juan manuel marquez
8 chad dawson
9 vitali klitschko
10 arthur abraham

 

I accept your apology.....

http://www.boxrec.com/media/index.php/The_Ring_Magazine's_Annual_Ratings:_1989

It's to do with both resume and skill.

 

@The OP

legit list, but I'd replace Haye for Paul Williams for the time being

 

Hopkins loses to Jermain Taylor twice and Calzaghe, and only beats Pavlik and Wright after making them move up and he is #3? Yet Juan Manueal fights Manny Pac your #1 and who is also a bigger guy then JMM to a draw and razor thin SD, then moves up and beats Cas and Diaz but loses to Floyd after gaining 15lbs to fight him and he is below Hops? Crazy talk.

Floyd
Manny
JMM
Williams
Mosley
Cotto
Dawson
Hopkins
Vitali
Haye

 

any list that has Vitali behind Wlad is seriously lacking. They weigh about the same and everyone knows Vitali is better than Wlad.

 

the vlad from now is better than vitali. you all think of vlads chin, but his defense is that good right now, that nobody will never ever test vlads chin, his defense is his all time great jab. he is faster than vitali and punches way harder

 

1-Manny Pacquiao
2-Floyd Mayweather
3-Shane Mosley
4-Juan Manuel Marquez
5-Bernard Hopkins
6-Miguel Cotto
7-Paul Williams
8-Nonito Donaire
9-Chad Dawson
10-David Haye

 

All in all I think this is a good solid list. Though personally I'd have Vitali and not Chad.

 

Pwill needs a few more fights b4 he can be considered

 

A few more fights????


He's like 37-1.


Eat ****, mother****er! :fire

 

Cheers! I put Dawson in there as he beat two well established fighters in his division, and seemed to show improvement in Johnson 2. Vitali had been out for a while, and i doubt the credibility of his wins over Arreola and Gomez as neither have really beaten top ten heavyweights themselves. But opinion is what counts :good

 

1, Mayweather
2, Pacquiao
3, Hopkins
4, Mosley
5, Marquez
6, Cotto
7, Wlad Klit
8, Vit Klit
9, Williams
10, Haye

 

I don't know where you get any of this information from, but you're posting wrong info and hopefully nobody thinks its correct. If you did research first, it'd be much better.

Theres more, but heres just 1 year for you since I don't want to type it all up.

KO Magazine
1988:
1. Mike Tyson
2. Julio Cesar Chavez
3. Evander Holyfield
4. Ray Leonard
5. Jeff Fenech
6. Michael Nunn
7. Azumah Nelson
8. Jung Koo Chang
9. Buddy McGirt
10. Sumbu Kalambay

Tyson was also number 1 in 1989.

 

poor list TS. Very poor