-My Top 10 P4P-

Calzaghe, Wright, Hopkins down
Cotto, Hatton up

 

Replace Calzaghe with Kessler or you'll be a laughing stock in four months...

 

1. Floyd Mayweather, Jr.
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Rafael Marquez
4. Winky Wright
5. Juan Manuel Marquez
6. Bernard Hopkins
7. Ricky Hatton
8. Miguel Cotto
9. Joe Calzaghe
10. Marco Antonio Barrera

 

At #5 for example?

He may be #3 if he beat Kessler.

 

He won't last the distance with Kessler... One good fight against overrated Lacy doesn't make him P4P 3rd. Look at the rest og his record. Floored against Salem and Mitchell. Kessler will kill him.

 

He isn't a dominat champion at his own weight class, at least untill he
beat Kessler so I guess he is at #5 on my list, below PBF, PAC, Marquez, Hopkins.

 

Mayweather
Wright
Pacquiao
Hatton
Taylor
Hopkins
J M Marquez
R Marquez
Mosley
Calzaghe

Cotto and Kessler almost make it

 

Are you going to put him into top p4p if he loses?

 

I'm pretty much in agreement with the first 5 more or less. Don't listen to the people saying put Calzaghe down. That is insanity if you compare him with the fighters they'd replace him with. It is very difficult to put Marquez, Winky (at this point in his career) above Joe. You can even use the ability argument to put Joe top in my opinion.