My top 20 P4P (visual evidence based)

no way a Heavyweight should make the list if we are talking based on films.

someone like Kalambay was at least twice as superior to any heavyweight I've seen and he rarely gets talked about here

 

1. Gomez
2. Lora
3. Canizales
4. Winstone
5. Chucho Castillo

And that's the end of that chapter.

 

where does Louis rank in your list?

 

Not bad. Would a loss to Pacquiao affect Floyd's spot?

 

no charles? well you can go sit on a spike sir

 

:goodits good

 

harry greb is not jesus christ

 

Erm... define sufficient? Particularly was thinking of Ezzard Charles. Not enough film on him for you or do you just not think much of him?

I see you got a new found respect in Armstrong. Don't remember him in the last list.

I could nitpick a few things. But it's your list. I think for me the biggest thing that stands out is Louis being below Hagler. I'd have him above, I think he looks superior on film. I guess you could always argue quality of opposition, but then again Louis was fighting much bigger men. Hagler... was fighting a fair share of great fighters coming up in weight.

 

Ricardo Lopez.......atschatschatsch:verysad:verysad:-(

 

harry greb
sam langford
joe gans
no evidence

 

I've never seen any film of sunglasses man yet somehow he manages to get on every list. Damn nostalgia bull****.

 

i like lopez on the list personally, especially if it's based on footage. despite the warranted complaint that there isn't a long of in fighting, he's damn near flawless in the footage we have