As I've criticized Tracy Callis' list,I thought I should put mine up to be shot at. In no order. Greb Robinson Charles Langford Armstrong Fitzsimmons Moore Walcott Original Duran Jofre Leonard B Gans Pep Wilde Leonard R Whittaker Ali Pacquiano Chavez McFarland/McGovern Reasonable list or worse than Callis'?
It's not a bad list, I think the inclusion of Pacquiao invites Mayweather as well I don't think Jofre, Chavez, Pacquiao, Whitaker or Walcott belong that high up, if Jofre does then you should look at Harada. That's just going on mine tho This content is protected Fair play for putting it up and yes, it is considerably better than Callis'
Yours is a fine list, though Ted Kid Lewis might be a trifle high for me since Jack Britton isn't included . Mayweather was close to being included in mine,as was Hearns.
I'm referring to the fact that mine are in no order, so nobody on my list is too high as regards others that are included.
Yes that was what I thought it was, I thought that a few were too high based on the fact they were in the top 20
Hearns would have destroyed Manny also, just ssaying because Manny and Floyd were mentioned above, but Manny was a one trick pony.
Hearns was way bigger. Ketchel would destroy Henry Armstrong, that doesn't mean he should be higher P4P.
