My top Feathers

Nice read, good effort in there too. Individual summarys are a nice touch on each fighters spec :good

 

if am to criticise, the last paragraph (Owens Rec) has bolder text :yep

 

Criticise.

Okay Jeffro, a very well thought out and respectable list but I'll have a go at you anyway.

Choi #1 fine

#2 should be Appelby
#3 Lindasy just about, he caught matthews with a lovely big swinger and laid him out but he was far from impressive

anyway, I'll give you a better arguemnet when I am sober. I do like your list though! always thought provoking!

 

Chuckles no1 end of argument.

The only reason I can see jeff putting him way down there is simply to wind my scottish up, surely there is no other logical reason?

If so please say, & make me laugh so much that I will need to reach for my inhaler.

 

No mate sorry, can't find anything to criticise there! Apart from maybe Appleby should be higher in the list. Nice post man

 

Didnt realise it was a top ten.

Matthews at 3 ? One of his top wins was against Simpson ?

Thaa Simpson fight was a shocker. The points etc were a complete **** up ! Given all his points deducted, did it not make it impossible for him to have won ? Or either Simpson never won a round ? Maybe am thinking of the wrong fight, got a feeling i aint.

 

only thing i would change is having an order. put them by there current british ranking.

i think lindsay and bhatia are the best of the lot.

 

i always thoguht matthews was a super featherweight tbh.i cant disagree with choi,buti would have had appleby up higher,wins over pickering and simpson deserves it

 

Theres no logical explanation in my mind for having Lindsay and Matthews above Appleby at present.

 

Good list,personally would have had Appelby ahead of Matthews but can c were your coming from he hasnt really been tested except against Simpson were it was seemingly a realy close fight again good list

 

Not qualified to criticise or comment, but liked the fact you had Choi on the list.:happy

Would you please comment on this thread, Jeff?:good

http://www.eastsideboxing.com/forum/showthread.php?t=122124