My welterweight rankings 2-12-2008

Mosley would beat Quintana as he has been at a higher level for a looooonger time and he faired muuuuch better against Cotto than El Indio. Heck, he nearly beat Miguel!

Also, isn't is obvious how Quintana, Williams, Margarito and Cintron stack in order? They all beat the guy I have listed below them. Makes sense, doesn't it? Especially because their accomplishments are fairly similar.

This is the correct list:

1 Mayweather
2 Cotto
3 Mosley
4 Quintana
5 Williams
6 Margarito
7 Cintron
8 Clottey
9 Collazo
10 Judah

 

Champ: Floyd Mayweather

1. Miguel Cotto
2. Shane Mosley
3. Carlos Quintana
4. Paul Williams
5. Antonio Margarito
6. Kermit Cintron
7. Zab Judah
8. Luis Collazo
9. Joshua Clottey
10. Andre Berto

 

Berto over Quintana, Williams, Margo, Cintron ...... atsch

 

1-Floyd
2-Cotto
3-Mosley
4-Quintana
5-Margarito
6-Paul Williams
7-Kermit Cintron
8-Louis Collazo
9-Andre Berto
10-Zab Judah

Once you get past 1-3, the competition is so deep that it gets real hard to put everyone in order. You got Margarito, Williams, Cintron and Quintana all bunched up because noone stands out between them. Margo beat Cintron, Williams beat Margo, Quintana beats Williams etc etc. Margo-Cintron II could do a lot to clean the list up.

 

How people have Margarito higher than Quintana and Williams bewilders me.

 

lolatsch :rofl :yep

 

1. Miguel Cotto
2. Floyd Mayweather
3. Shane Mosley
4. Carlos Quintana
5. Antonio Margarito
6. Zab Judah
7. Paul Williams
8. Kermit Cintron
9. Joshua Clottey
10. Andre Berto
11. Luis Collazo

 

mosley needs to be higher

 

because many felt that their speed would give Cotto trouble and felt he had a chance of losing those fights...I was actually impress before those fights...Paulie, and Quintana was impressive as well... Judah and Mosley was just the icing on the cake.

 

atsch
There are so many things wrong with this post I don't even know where to start

 

1. Mayweather
2. Cotto
3. Mosley
4. Quintana
5. Margarito
6. Williams
7. Cintron
8. Clottey
9. Soto Karass
10. Berto
11. Collazo
12. Nuzhnenko
13. Gomez
14. Judah
15. Hlatswayo

Problem is that nobody from #7 down has beaten anyone that good, or the ones who have (Judah and Hlathswayo) have had brutal losses more recently. I personally think some of these guys (esp Collazo) are very overrated by some. People give Collazo too much credit for almost beating Ricky Hatton and barely beating a very faded JA Rivera.

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by mney mayweather
Berto is the next big thing in the division he deserves more respect. miguel cotto is going to fight in Berto's shadow. cotto will never be undisputed welterweight. berto deserves respect he has not shyed away from the big fights. he could easily of lost 7 pounds and gone down to light welter and become a world champ by now but he wants to take on the best.

AGREED!

 

Damn...this must be the dumbest post I've read in a while. This is proof that lead poisoning and inbreeding is a combination that will one day destroy the earth:deal

 

Thats not bad.
Except, Paul Williams belongs at the bottom of the list (if that).
Your as good as your last fight which for Paul Williams was pathetic.
His ability to make 147 is very questionable.
Fight nite he weighed +160 and he still had nothing.
I suggest that he doesnt belong on this list until he shows otherwise.