My World and British p4p rankings- agree or disagree?

No idea how you have Walters in your list .the main is the biggest weight drainer in boxing his a welterweight I'd say and his two most noticable wins are against shot past there prime flyweights

 

Roman Gonzalez?

 

Khan has done more than Kell on the world stage.

Where's "Chocalito"and Manny?

 

he is small, you might not have seen him.


Loads of people seem to forget about lil Roman, done it myself in conversations.

 

A distinct lack of Lomachenko.

 

on ability / past glories I'd have ward in there, but since he's done nothing for 3/4 years now, I wouldn't have him in.

Think d Garcia deserves to be there, he's unbeaten (according to the record books he is anyway) with wins over mattysse, Peterson, khan, Judah etc and all but cleaned up at LWW.

I'd have Tim Bradley on there too, and take cotto out as he's beaten a crocked Martinez but to me has lost most of his big fights, - though that may change after tomorrow night.

Agree in the main with the list though, I always struggle to do these lists - I think khan would beat brook, but can't really justify placing khan above brook on what they've done in the last 3/4 years.

 

GGG 1st hahaha

 

I actually think your lists are of a good quality, judgement wise in my humble opinion. Realistically people will always have a few people different to the next man then have a different order.

I will have ago, then properly remember I have forgot someone.

World

GGG
Rigo
Gonzalaz
Ward
Klitcksko
Kovalev
Lomanchenko
Pacman
Canelo
Cotto

And just missing out Brook (might not have beat a host of big stars yet but I am sure he will). Styles make fights e.g, for example most will disagree but I think Brook beats pacman now at 147ibs.

British

Brook
Selby
Quigg
Khan
Frampton
J McDonnell
C Smith
DeGale
Campbell
Joshua

The one closest to getting in is Flanaghan

 

Name me 10 better welters than him...

 

What has Kell done bar beat Porter?

 

that's better than anything khans done since he beat Judah though. To flip the question, whats khan done to be ranked ahead of brook since they've been competing in the same division for around 2 years?