Name a fight where your opinion is completely against the consensus.

Why dont you put it as a new thread / poll , infact here is the title for you :

Was Shane Mosley behind against Mayorga before scoring a KO !!!!!!!

 

Berto vs Collazo.
For sure i thought Louie had done enought to win.
Kinda hope Collazo win his rematch although i really appreciate Andre Berto.

 

Added to that it was Setanta who aired the fight not Sky so you can try and straighten out your facts , check out the new poll , may the best man win !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

I had Norton beating Ali in all 3 of their fights.

 

i scored both fights for marquez over pacman

i scored both fights for hopkins over taylor

i had spinks beating taylor

 

there was NO WAY they were gonna give him the fight after the **** from the first match

 

Wrong again....it was on sky!!! And I just checked the internet to confirm!!! I'll expect your apology.

 

I thought Clottey beat Cotto
I thought Spinks beat Taylor

Edit
I thought Winky beat Vargas
I thought Pea beat Oscar
I thought Quartey beat Oscar

 

Niether of those are completly against the consensus. jsut start a poll and you'll see we're about evenly split on those fights. As far as Spinks and Taylor go, I think most people know that Spinks won that fight but just refuse to score for a guy that absolutly refuses to engage.

 

:-(

Most people get laughed at on the General Forum if they even so much as say Oscar took more than 3-4 rounds in his fight with Mayweather.

 

Ah, but that's just ESB GF. :think I guess the OP didn't specify "consensus among boxing folk" or "consensus on ESB".

 

I think Pac beat Marquez twice
I think Mayweather beat Castillo in their first fight
I think Hopkins beat Calzaghe
I think Taylor beat Hopkins in their first fight

 

I've got almost no problem with Shane winning the second Hoya fight.

 

I thought mayorga should have won against spinks. he was not given credit for the knockdowns that he scored in one case spinks kind of threw himself down to avoid a shot which is the same as taking a knee IMO and I don't think that a point deduction was justified. You take away that point deduction and give Mayorga rightfull credit for the knockdowns and that fight goes his was on the score cards.

 

I told everyone Mosely would knock out Margarito I even wrote a thread on these forums I was scoffed at, my boys laughed in my face I would argue the discussions heated I was positive Mosley would do it based on styles and Mosely's strengths and Margos weaknesses. I looked like a damn genius fight night and established my cred with many an idiot who now view me as an informed fan and even request my insight what a difference 1 fight makes.