Name me ONE definite at-or-near prime future Hall of Famer that Mayweather beat

:roll: Sure.

 

No ones questioning his ATG-ness. He is an ATG.

 

Yes, they are ATG Heavyweights, and they are ATG's. Not Top 75, though in terms of greatness. Alexis Arguello IMO is the greatest super featherweight of all time, that does not mean he's a Top 40 ATG for example..in my book at least.

 

General forum is ok sometimes, but it's mostly gutter trash based on racism. For a serious boxing talk, Classic is where it's at.

 

Who said my limit was 75 guys?

Btw..I'm not so much a fan of Money May, but I am one of the biggest fans of PBF.

 

That's alright. Tbh you may also misunderstand what comes across as 'hate', but it's really a testament to how great I think Mayweather is. I'm holding him to the highest standard championed by the TBE's before him. That's why it seems very cut-throat but it's ultimately all nit picking, but this whole construct is a boxing forum where we all discuss and dissect - people forget that and start feeling all kinds of butthurt. Because I think they're ridiculous for their butthurt, I like toying with these guys.

At the end of the day, even though I call the older version of him Duck Runhugger and think there's a lot of truth to it, boxing is such that his more recent awful style still counts as boxing even though it doesn't show as much mastery defensively than his earlier days..nor does it show mastery on the level of a Pernell Whitaker who was able to reaallly fight whilst being slick.

 

Whitaker had more fights in a shorter period of time, ring age is the thing to consider. But not only that, Whitaker fought the better top names in the condition they were in.

Floyd Mayweather isn't going to be as good as Hopkins is at age 49.