NAOYA INOUE IS THE P4P KING!!!!!!!!!

I still think Usyk has the better resume. He cleared out the CW division, became undipsuted, and then beat one of the better HWs and is now one of the best HW champions. Him beating Fury would most likely cement his superiority.

 

Disagree. Donaire in his prime was more elusive and quicker with his hands. Inoue would have had major trouble against a prime Donaire for sure.
As far as Usyk goes, hes beaten guys who he wasnt favored to beat and most of the time made it look easy. How many times has Inoue been the underdog in a fight? Never. Hes never really been tested in a fight where you can say, damn inoue lost that. Usyk over Inoue.

 

If you turn the table around Inoue was 39 and Donaire was the 30 prime boxer. But the more I think. You know Inoues power is legit top 3 today in the game. Those shots would have dropped prime Donaire. But it doesn't take away the fact that Donaire has had a lot of WARS and mileage on the clock. He looked done a few years ago. Some people think beating Quabali and Gaballo somehow he is back. No! no way. I don't think this is the case. Quaballi and France were never a force in baxxing. Gaballo well he is what he is just another boxer that not good enough at the top level. Just another so so boxer. Had he beat the authentic champion like 3 division world champion Casimero. Then I would have taken notice. But no don't sweat the techniques.

 

Sunny Edwards shouldn't even be in the discussion. And I'm sure he'll be able to become undisputed at BW this year and perhaps be undisputed at Super BW next year. Hope that happens.

 

There is plenty of reason not to. 140 has the most boxers. Look at what happens when 135ers move up to fight 140ers. 9/10 times the moving up top champ at LW destroys 140, it's inferior despite having more boxers.

 

Inoue’s best win is a fight in which he got his face caved in by a guy almost in his 40s.

Inoue’s 2nd best win is against the same 40-year-old guy 3 years later, clearly shot to pieces.

Naoya Inoue: extremely skilled fighter, tragic resume, has even more tragic fanboys.

 

Besides, by your logic, because Cuba is such a small country, they couldn't have the talent to dominate the USA and all other countries in amateur boxing. Yet they have, consistently, for decades.

 

Inoue P4P number 1 on the eye test but resume still lacking a bit when compared against Usyk and even Crawford to a lesser extent

 

Its an opinion. A fact would be Pac getting koed in 6, or Canelo getting outboxed by Bivol