New p4p list!

A simple question to all of you. Why is it or why is too important to you the P4P rankings? Do you really think that it counts when it comes to decide whether a boxer makes it to the HOF? Do you really think they keep track of that? Do you think that you have to be at some point in time in the top ten P4P in order to be a HOFer?

 

Just Check where SRL, Duran, SRR & Pep was rated during their Prime years & you'll get your answer.

 

Wrong answer. Mayorga was in the top ten. Do you thing he is or he will be a HOFer?

 

Those guys i mentioned becomes #1 or #2 P4P during their time. Mayorga becomes I think #8 but only keep it for months not even a year.

 

So.... that means that it is irrelevant....isn't it?

 

Mayweather
Pacquiao
Calzaghe

thats how I see the top 3.

 

hmm... if pac beat a shot barrera, then marquez won against a shot barrera too... so, what is marquez doing at #3 p4p? :huh

 

Exactly. The p4p list is a showcase. It is subjective. It means nothing after all. Isn't it?

 

JC up there tied with Pac at #2.:good

A win against Bhops would put him in the #1 slot in my book...

 

3rd spot...

 

PBF
Pac
Cal

 

Theres very few guys who can make fun of Pacs record and try twist it. PBF has Mitchell, Judah, Baldo and old DLH. I respect it enough but it could just as easily be twisted.

 

#3 above jmm. the juarez fight didn't do anything to enhance jmm's resume. jmm beat the guy who lost 2X to the guy he previously beat (barrera).

 

1. Hatton/Mayweather
2. Calzaghe

 

Good list. You may shuffle 3 and 4 if you wish but still overall good list.