New P4P Rankings!!!!

This is my care-ometer:


||

 

thank you. so you had jmm and pac as the top 2 boxers currently and bhop and others lagging far at #3 and so on. i have the same opinion that pac and jmm are miles ahead of the others though i have pac as clear #1.

 

He's really not, but anyone can come up with a P4P list. I have Big Bird at #3 on my P4P Rankings and Oscar the Grouch is sitting pretty at #1. I'm sure Bert and Ernie will take this seriously.

 

I dont know I'd put Floyd 1st automatically if he came back...I mean he never lost his lb 4 lb title but than again he hasn't fought in a year and a half..I think Id rather have him fight the #1 to get it back...He'd beat Pac pretty easy!

 

almost every top fighter is talking retirement yet the old man had no plans yet because he still not having a payday he deserve...well, if he doesnt lost to john, he doesnt have to rebuild his career...

point is, he lost two years trying to bounce back after the john loss as pacquiao, calzaghe, morales, barrera, hopkins, mayweather, vazquez, de la hoya, pavlik and jones are busy making LEGACY and putting money in their POCKETS...

 

Bad move on your part to send a WW to fight the top dogs of the other planets. At least choose the best HW out there. So far this title belongs to Wlad. Who do you think will win between Floyd and Wlad?

 

How can you have Dawson in your top 10 and not Hatton??

 

why is Izzy and Rafa still top 10 when theyve been on the shelf for such a long time ... I give Izzy a pass because he was hurt ... but Rafa has been passing up on fights with Lopez, Caballero, and other top junior feathers ...

And its a shame that Vic Darchinyan isn't in the top top ... he's not boarderline top 10 .. he's a legit top 10 fighter.

 

If Floyd comes back, my rankings goes as follows:

1. Pac - he's earned the spot and wouldn't be fair to take it away from him
2. JMM
3. Hopkins
4. Shane
5. Izzy V
6. Ivan Calderon
7. Vic Darchinyan
8. Dawson
9. Rafa Marquez
10. Ricky Hatton

 

Here it is!!! Another proof the whole P4P concept is nothing but bull****. 1,000,000 different P4p lists posted every week. None of them can explain the standards used to rank this fighters. :----(

 

He doesn't make your top 10 if he comes back?

 

Does he deserve a spot because of his name?????? Hell no!!.
Let him beat some real opponent in his weight class and who is not about to retire and then we can give him a spot.

 

My cretiria would be ....

Weight classes competed in
Top 10 fighters faced including champions
Championships won

*Mosley fought Mayorga at 154 then beat Margarito at 147
*Paul Williams beat Quintana(champion at the time), then went up in weight to beat Phillips (who was a champion) then he went up in weight again to beat Andy Kolle - Winky Wright ...
*Darchinyan, lost his title to Donaire, came back to become the unified champion at a higher weight class. beating a top 10 p4p fighter in Mijares.
*Dawson has been up and down in weight his whole career ... middleweight, super middleweight and light heavyweight ... won minor titles at all 3 weight classes - beat the biggest - undefeated Adamek (who went on to become the cruiserweight champion and still only has one loss)