New Ring P4P: Pac, PBF, JMM, Donaire, Shane...

it's ****ing Mythical... that p4p ranking. so i can understand everyone arguing.

Look at the bright side the top 2 dogs can fight in the same weight class! yey!


btw... I'd like to know the rationale behind Donaire's inclusion.

 

Front on what? Is there an age restriction on being a belt holder? Last time I checked the only requirement was being able to pass the physicals and being bad enough to win. Last time I checked Mosley passed with flying colors.

Age is irrelevant. Ask people who got whooped by Big George, B-Hop, and Glen Johnson. What matters is you RANKING!

Man I swear you guys are like chicks. :yep

 

Still no Wlad? Shane and Donaire top 5?

Well, at least they had the chutzpah to shake up the lower part of the list a bit. It's a start.

 

Wow, P4P is just an opinion and everybody has their right to have one, but wow. The Ring has the shittest P4P ranking I've seen.

 

No, I wasn't impressed by any of those things because Hatton had already been schooled and KO'ed by Floyd Mayweather Jr previously and hadn't looked anywhere near as good since.

Cotto again, obliterated by Mosley and scraped past Clottey - damaged goods.

ODLH? Weight drained and old.

I was more impressed by Pacquaio beating Clottey. That represented a guy who had taken some pretty good guys very close, had not been obliterated, was unlucky to lose to both Cotto and Marg.

 

**** THAT is what everybody is SAYING. I GEUSS THEY know pac is going out the DOOR and they dont know WHAT TO DO ABOUT THERE NEXT SUPERSTAR they still got BOOM BOOM...

 

it would be nice for some of u here to apply for a position as the Ring's analyst.

 

WHAT RINGS ANAL:huh

 

They should have took pac's #1 spot away from him while he was still active as a way to hurt his ego. Maybe they could have peer pressured him into signing the contract.

 

Oh really? I recall you had a this long pre-fight analysis and prediction of how Pac would not be able to handle Cotto. Pac destroyed Cotto. Now that victory is not impressive or even worth mentioning to you?

 

Honestly, p4p in my opinion is turning into ajoke. Like I wouldn't rate half these losers on here.

 

:good

 

Donaire does not deserve to be number 4....

 

That seems to be the one point that brings everyone agrees on!

 

i'd like to see montiel in there. but i agree with pac being at number 1 and floyd at number 2