NEW Ring P4P Rankings

Again Cotto gets overated by ESBers and Hatton gets underated.

Hatton loses the Floyd he gets chucked out,

But cotto loses to a Margo who wasn't in the top 20 but he stays 7-9 on most ppls list:huh

 

Move Calzaghe to nr 8 and take out Hatton of top 10, Wladimir should also be there

 

And Dawson and Williams haven't done enough to get top 10 rated

 

Mines.....

1. Pac
2. JMM
3. Calzaghe
4. Hopkins
5. Vazquez
6. Mosley
7. Cotto
8. Rafael Marquez
9. Vic Darchinyan
10. Dawson

 

I don't agree that Mosley should be bumped up so high after one good win.... Dawson has not done enough imo..... and Cotto should be outta there

 

yes the top 7 are spot on, very good
the other 3 need abit of work

cotto should be in there and hatton should be 10

oh and take cabellero out and bring paul williams

 

Mine is....

1) Pac
2) JMM
3) Calzaghe
4) B-Hop
5) Vasquez
6) Mosley
7) Hatton
8) Cotto
9) Darchinyan
10) Calderon

Honourable mentions; P-Dub, Dawson, Adamek, Haye, Rafael Marquez.

 

:--(

 

Who would you have in there then ???

 

Wheres your list?

 

Hatton is severely underrated. He beat all of the top contenders when he was at 140 lbs (except Mayweather, who he later fought at WW, and Cotto, whom he didn't duck by any means, they just never got to fight, which is a shame) and has recently beaten one of the top contenders in his division and is gearing up to fight the P4P no.1 (the second time in two years he has fought the P4P no.1)

Once that has happened he will either fight the P4P no.2/3 (Marquez) one of the top LW's in Juan Diaz, or have another superfight with Mosley/DLH/Cotto/PBF (all except DLH will beat him though)

He's up there with the best, and although his style is not always crowd pleasing, he is a powerful puncher who rarely takes a backwards step, has underrated footspeed and movement, and despite a few bad performances, is a two0weight champion whose sole loss came to a modern great and the then P4P no.1

He belongs in the top ten, no doubt.

 

1) Pacman
2) Calzhage
3) JMM
4) B-Hop
5) Vasquez
6) R. Marquez
7) Hatton
8 Mosley
9) Darchinyan
10) Calderon

Just out... Cotto, Dawson, Adamek, Haye, Wlad

 

Looks fine to me.

 

Why Rafa and no Cotto?

 

I guess it's because he got totally beat up by Margo who just got totally outclassed by a 37 year old past best Mosley.