*NEW* The Ring P4P Rankings - Cotto is GONE!

ewwwwww smells like:

This content is protected

 

you do some research. mosely is ranked #5 now but wasn't top 10 when cotto fought him, and would lose to him in a rematch. judah was coming off 2 straight losses when he fough cotto. and what about malignaggi and quintana?

where did i say cabaellero does? i was replying to a post about cotto.

 

Hatton has no business being there after getting bailed out vs Lazcano.

 

you obviosuly are dumb or have reading comprehension difficulties. everything i said was FACT. if you can point out anything i said in that post that wasn't true i'll take it back, but i won't have to.

here i'll repeat it:

he hasn't beaten a p4p top 10 fighter yet

he's only ever fought for vacant titles

he was made to quit in his last (proper) fight by a fighter who wasn't in the top 25 p4p before the fight. (subjective but he was no where near top 10)

 

Agree, why would Cotto lose to Mosley. Margo lost because he had no Plan B, it wasn;t like Mosley fought any differently against Cotto, he caught him with some great shots.

I love the way Margo made Cotto 'quit' when he probably had plaster on his hands and hit Cotto well over a hundred times before he gave up!!!

I like Hatton, but I think that guy is a Cotto hater.

 

Cotto is a p4p fighter. Those that don't have him in there show their knowledge. The man lost in a classic to a fighter who may have cheated.

 

no that was obviosuly opinion. as far as mosely he wasn't top 10 p4p when cotto fought him what is there to dispute? cotto is not even the best in his division, (this is opinion) williams beats him, margo beats him in a rematch and i would favour mosely in a rematch who was getting the upper hand towards the end of the fight.

 

I think Darchiniyan is actually deserving of a spot . .
I just dont agree with rankings and the dismissal of my boy Cotto.

 

Really? Hatton beat two P4P-ers and became the undisputed, lineal LWW champion, and still is. Only loss is to Mayweather, the P4P king outside of his division.

Cotto beat ZERO P4P-ers when the fights happened, neither Judah or Mosley were ranked back then. Got whooped by Margarito, not ranked in any top20P4P at the time. He came back vs. a no hoper. Hatton came back vs. The Ring #1 ranked LWW Paulie Malignaggi, and won almost every round and stopped him, something Cotto failed to do.

So... at the moment, why would Cotto, an excellent fighter, be ranked in the top10? If he can beat Mosley again, a bit more convincingly than the last time, he'll be a legitimate top10 again. And don't come with the plaster controversy, we unfortunately can't judge whether Tony cheated in that fight or not.

Darchinyan: P4P-er Mijares, KO, champion Kirilov, TKO, champion Arce, TKO, now undisputed SFW champion.

I have absolutely no idea WTF is Caballero doing there, nor anyone else including other experts. Seriously. WTF is he doing there?

 

Just more evidence the whole P4P doesn't mean ****. Mosley wasn't P4P when he fought Cotto but now he is???? Does that mean he wasn't good when he fought Cotto??? He has done two fights after that Mayorga(NEVER P4P) and Margacheato without the casts!!


So, I guess by this measuring tools that are being used I can make a case for another fight to be included. A boxer who beat Mosley twice and beat Trinidad. I will put Winky in my list!!!!! Why???? Because is my ****ing list!!!!!! And I think he has an awesome defense and great boxing skills. Even if a lot of people think he is boring. So, **** it, from now on, he is on my list.:hi::hi::hi::hi:

 

Let's not forget Hatton/Collazo. I can't forget that one!

 

As a huge Vic D fan I gotta say.... He is not deserved of P4P top 10 status. He's leathal sure, but he's fairly limited and his win over Arce didn't prove too muc in my eyes.