Of the Fab 4 Leonard, Hearns, Duran, Haglar, Rate there attributes 1 to 10.

TheSouthpaw · Mar 1, 2013

DaveK said: ↑

Because this is an exercise in gay futility.

Obviously all these guys had ATG skills and qualities, and narrowing their qualities down to the things listed is doing them a disservice, plus, your ratings are all ****ed up- there's nothing to choose between them by your ratings. You're splitting hairs, and not very accurately.

This would probably be better if there was weight/p4p status given, but it's tough when you have a lightweight that got some work done at 154, and 160, two ww's that had some notable fights at or around 160, and then a natural, career mw...

Are we to rate them all at 147 except Hagler?

If you stipulated in a pound for pound sense, yes, but it's confusing the way it's stated.[/quote

Thanks Dave..How would you have worded them!?..........
Click to expand...

anj · Mar 2, 2013

No Mas does not allow me to give Duran's heart a 10, no way in hell.

duranimal · Mar 2, 2013

anj said: ↑

No Mas does not allow me to give Duran's heart a 10, no way in hell.
Click to expand...

It had **** all to do with his heart. You question a man who went in with Hagler?? whilst other feint-hearts faked retirements & injuries to avoid their date with certain ****ing doom!!! Duran stepped up to face the monster!! Don't ever question the heart of a warrior who ruled a division like a tyranasour & the stepped up to defeat the universally accepted P4P king. Bring upon himself such self inflicted humiliation that would have crushed 99% of mankind & then stepped back out into the spotlight so the haha hehe brigade could sni$$er & snipe at a fat washed up pug. But that fat washed up pug near on beat the mighty Hagler then faced his doom against Hearns who outreached him by a ****ing 1ft & then proceeded at 37 to deck the Monster in Iran Barkley who'd just obliterated Hearns & you question his ****ing heart!!! YOU ****!!

Goyourownway · Mar 2, 2013

This content is protected

DaveK · Mar 2, 2013

duranimal said: ↑

It had **** all to do with his heart. You question a man who went in with Hagler?? whilst other feint-hearts faked retirements & injuries to avoid their date with certain ****ing doom!!! Duran stepped up to face the monster!! Don't ever question the heart of a warrior who ruled a division like a tyranasour & the stepped up to defeat the universally accepted P4P king. Bring upon himself such self inflicted humiliation that would have crushed 99% of mankind & then stepped back out into the spotlight so the haha hehe brigade could sni$$er & snipe at a fat washed up pug. But that fat washed up pug near on beat the mighty Hagler then faced his doom against Hearns who outreached him by a ****ing 1ft & then proceeded at 37 to deck the Monster in Iran Barkley who'd just obliterated Hearns & you question his ****ing heart!!! YOU ****!!
Click to expand...

Im sensing some bias....

TheSouthpaw · Mar 2, 2013

DaveK said: ↑

Because this is an exercise in gay futility.

Obviously all these guys had ATG skills and qualities, and narrowing their qualities down to the things listed is doing them a disservice, plus, your ratings are all ****ed up- there's nothing to choose between them by your ratings. You're splitting hairs, and not very accurately.

This would probably be better if there was weight/p4p status given, but it's tough when you have a lightweight that got some work done at 154, and 160, two ww's that had some notable fights at or around 160, and then a natural, career mw...

Are we to rate them all at 147 except Hagler?

If you stipulated in a pound for pound sense, yes, but it's confusing the way it's stated.
Click to expand...

No not P4P....Just rate the attributes that are listed...I dont see how im splitting hairs here and I dont know how else to say it!...This had nothin to do with weightclass, but if it helps rank them from a " when they were in there prime aspect ".....Sorry to disappoint Dave!

TheSouthpaw · Mar 2, 2013

I re tweeked a few attributes...including Durans heart...The Mas thing doesnt help him there

TheSouthpaw · Mar 2, 2013

Nagabilly said: ↑

I'll give it a try:

This is based on P4P. Which means 135 Duran, 147 Leonard/Hearns, 160 Hagler

Power:
1. Hearns (obvious)
There rest are pretty close, but...
2. Duran
3. Hagler
4. Leonard

Speed
1. Leonard
Again it's close
2. Hearns
3. Hagler
4. Duran

Defense
1. Duran
2. Hagler
3. Leonard
4. Hearns

Offense is a bit difficult IMO I'll need time to determine my rankings. Not going to bother with heart they're warriors who are all equal in that catergory.
Click to expand...

Great list..put together very wel!:good

Log in or Sign up

Of the Fab 4 Leonard, Hearns, Duran, Haglar, Rate there attributes 1 to 10.

TheSouthpaw Champion Full Member

anj Guest

duranimal Boxing Junkie Full Member

Goyourownway Insanity enthusiast Full Member

DaveK Vicious & Malicious Full Member

TheSouthpaw Champion Full Member

TheSouthpaw Champion Full Member

TheSouthpaw Champion Full Member

Log in or Sign up

Forums

Of the Fab 4 Leonard, Hearns, Duran, Haglar, Rate there attributes 1 to 10.

TheSouthpaw Champion Full Member

anj Guest

duranimal Boxing Junkie Full Member

Goyourownway Insanity enthusiast Full Member

DaveK Vicious & Malicious Full Member

TheSouthpaw Champion Full Member

TheSouthpaw Champion Full Member

TheSouthpaw Champion Full Member