**OFFICIAL**: Incompetent/Corrupt Judges Thread.

I'll bump this again if there is a terrible scorecard. Maybe, we will see a pattern with certain judges.


I'll start it off with:

Benoit Roussel:

114-114 in Funeka/Guzman
114-112 for Campbell over Funeka

Pierre Benoist

119-110 for Williams over Martinez

Tom Kaczmarek

116-110 for Cintron over Martinez.

Gale E. Van Hoy

118-110 for Diaz over Malignaggi

 

If this thread is aimed at recent poor judging, I'd nominate the dude who jobbed my boy Chambers against Dimitrenko: Paul Thomas, 113-113atsch. Also, all three judges who went for Sturm over Gevor: Raul Caiz 115-113 | Ruben Garcia, Dr. 115-113 | Daniel Talon 117-111.

 

I'll try to aggregate a bit in this post. I'm pretty interested by this one.

Eugenia Williams
115-113 for Holyfield over Lewis

Doug Tucker
120-108 for Navarro over Mijares
117-110 for Toney over McCallum II
119-109 for Griffin over Toney II

Daniel Talon
117-111 Sturm over Gevor

Glenn Feldman
115-113 Coleman over Arnaoutis

Kevin Morgan
115-113 Coleman over Arnaoutis

Frank Lombardi
114-113 Casamayor over Santa Cruz

Ron McNair
114-113 Casamayor over Santa Cruz

Terry O'Connor
98-92 Fury over McDermott

Dalby Shirley
114-113 Rubio over Ouma

Paul Thomas
113-113 Dimitrenko against Chambers

Benoit Roussel:
114-114 in Funeka/Guzman

Pierre Benoist
119-110 for Williams over Martinez

Tom Kaczmarek
116-110 for Cintron over Martinez.

Gale E. Van Hoy
118-110 for Diaz over Malignaggi
114-114 for John vs. Juarez I
117-111 Taylor over Spinks

Glen Hamada
115-113 Katsidis over Diaz

Jerry Roth
Hopkins over Taylor in fight 1 116-112
Trinidad over De La Hoya 115-113
Boudouani over Jones 116-112
De La Hoya over Whitaker 116-110
Foreman over Schulz 115-113
Pazienza over Duran in fight 1 117-112

 

What about the guiy who scored the lopsided victory for Cotto over Joshua Clottey?

 

All British referees with their bull**** stoppages :deal

 

That ref from Calzaghe/MAnfredo fight needs to be hanged.

 

will u ever be able to look at Frankie Gavin the same again

 

That was also Terry O'Connor (the guy who screwed the pooch on Fury-McDermott)

 

Correct.:good

 

I was just about to mention Mr Tucker. It was in fact the Jose Navarro fight that he scored 120-108 - in Navarro's favour. However, you could still mention the Munoz fight. Gustavo Padilla scored it 115-113 to Munoz in a fight he won no more than 2 or 3 rounds in.

 

Someone needs to build a website dedicated to exposing/embarrassing poor judging.

Another thought: encourage boxrec to post rnd x rnd scorecards with each fight they log.

Also, no letting judges off just because the fight didn't go to the cards or the right guy still won...

Tyson/Douglas at time of stoppage...
Ken Morita 87-86 (Tyson)| Masakazu Uchida 86-86

 

Jerry Roth

Hopkins over Taylor in fight 1 116-112
Trinidad over De La Hoya 115-113
Boudouani over Jones 116-112
De La Hoya over Whitaker 116-110
Foreman over Schulz 115-113
Pazienza over Duran in fight 1 117-112

 

Gale E. Van Hoy
118-110 for Diaz over Malignaggi
114-114 for John vs. Juarez I
117-111 Taylor over Spinks

Gale Van Hoy not looking so great. First two are TERRIBLE. I can understand the Taylor/Spinks scorecard to some extent because Spinks ran all night.

 

That's a good idea. Most people could care less if it's stopped early but it does still matter.

 

This might be the worst of the lot