Ring Magazine and Transnational Boxing Rangkings highly disagree with you. Those two bodies also happen to me much bigger authority on P4P rankings than you. They both have Golovkin and Kovalev above Andre Ward. This must really make your skin crawl. Eat your heart out. :rofl
First of all, it's not ALL about resume...as I pointed out, there are guys with great resumes that are not listed. there's also a subjective component. It's a combination of a number of different factors...i have subjective criteria such as, for example, the PRIME of a fighter...a young guy in his early-mid 20's who has accomplished more than a guy 10 years older is gonna be rated higher...that's one of many things to consider besides resume, quality of wins, ability to prove oneself at different weight classes, etc. 1- Andre ward = the best resume of all, hands down. 2- Erislandy Lara = another great resume...beat the likes of williams, vanes, canelo, trout etc, etc... in reality, an undefeated fighter who has faced and defeated the cream of the crop at jmw and mw. 3- Terrence Crawford = don't see a reason for anyone to argue about this, but has demonstrated a superior skillset over great to respectable opposition in two weight classes. 4- Errol Spence =ok, i can see how some might take issue with this, but spence falls into the category of a young fighter who has done more than guys who have been around much longer...and against top level talent. obliterated algieri, a guy who gave khan fits and went 12 with pac and beat the likes of provodnikov. 5- rigondeaux = a master boxer who dominates elite guys with seeming ease....dropped a few spots due to inactivity. 6- roman gonzalez= a little overhyped, but still an elite talent. 7- manny pacquiao = still a force to be reckoned with....although his entire career is suspect. 8- Deontay wilder = given the vlad-fury debacle, wilder is the best hw by default. 9- Canelo Alvarez = a proven talent who has fought the best and usually acquitted himself well...marred by cowardly turn for the worse recently. 10- james degale= convincingly beat the extravagantly talented andre dirrell and a bute who was juiced to the gills...the best at smw.
first of all, the guys who write for ring magazine are just some dudes to me...their opinion is as meaningful as yours. secondly, Ring magazine needs to put white guys on their list because they depend on white customers to buy their magazines....therefore, ring magazine has an agenda. same as espn and other so-called rankings that are really just politics. I, on the other hand, have NO agenda...i gain NOTHING by placing anybody strategically on a list or by omitting anybody....that makes me a whole lot more credible than ring magazine and any other commercial source. the fact is golovkin has done NOTHING to earn a place in anybody's top ten....you might THINK he's talented, but he hasn't PROVEN it against any fighter of quality. kkkovalev is more proven...but against whom? 49 year old hopkins?...washed up, past his prime pascal? i consider errol spence dispatching of algieri to be far more impressive...
Great thread. I assumed when all of cereals threads got deleted yesterday without explaination that the mods had made a grave mistake and banned cereal the greatest poster on this forum, thankfully they haven't banned him and he is here to stay and spread he's knowledge
Spence beat nobody. Crawford only beat featherweight Gamboa who is much smaller than him. Wilder beat nobody, he is an unskilled tomato can crushing fraud, true definition of a paper champ. DeGale lost to George Groves. Your list is terrible and you're a moron.
1. Gonzales 2. Kovalev 3. Rigo 4. Lomachenko 5. Ward 6. Fury/Klitschko winner 7. Golovkin 8. Postol/Crawford winner 9. Lebedev 10. Alvarez Here is a list for people that don't fall into racist inbreed "demographic" that OP represents. I have him on ignore so I haven't seen his list, but I imagine it has the ghettos finest (Broner) in the top and the rest of the names are black.
well, if spence beat nobody, kkkovalev and ggg beat LESS than nobody, because NOBODY on their records can touch algieri.