Oliver McCall vs the following prime fighters

I can see him beating Carnera and Galento. Probably Buddy Baer too given his amazing chin. Max Baer would probably win decision. Sharkey would school him.

 

He beats them all on the right night.

 

I'd only favour him over Galento and Buddy.

 

I don't know, with Mccall, he's such an hot and cold guy. Never know which version turns up.
Anyway assuming he turns in his absolute best performance against these fellas, I'd say
He kos Buddy Baer in 10.
Stops Galento in 6
Kos Carnera but it's an akward fight.
Draws with Sharkey
Loses on point s to Schmeling.
Loses on points to Max Baer.

 

Forgot to add Schmeling - he'd clearly outbox him to decision.

 

If he doesn't break down and start crying!!! He's not tough enough mentally...

 

I'd add Carnera to the list and I'm solid with it

 

McCall knocks em all with the exception of maybe Schmeling, who I still think he could reasonably beat.

 

There is no reason to bet on McCall knocking out Sharkey or Baer.

 

There is for me. Sharkey, though a decent fighter in most areas, was ordinary to me, and would get knocked. McCall was far more concentrated than Baer, and indestructible, and therefore I have him beating Baer.