On second watch, were these fights really robberies...?

gayweather vs. castillo 1.

 

*adds Peejay to ignore*

 

Only mathysse vs alexander was a clear robbery the others 2 were closer allthough I had lucas and jmm winning.
I place them under controversial decision, but not controversial enough that you have to respect the decision like jmm vs pac 1/2 or pea vs oscar.
I felt hopkins vs pascal 1 was a robbery but after rewatching it I guess you can make a case for a draw, I really felt hopkins got screwed out of his legendary accomplishment right then, really pissed off.

 

marquez v pac x 3

3 robberies.

 

The 2 Matthysse fights were robberies. There's always that point that close fights can't be robberies, but that just isn't true.
if it's over 12 rounds, and one wins 6 clearly, loses 3 rounds and 3 can go either way it isn't a robbery if it's a draw (just a bit suspect). But if the guy loses it suddenly becomes a robbery, because no case can be made for the other guy winning more as all of the close rounds.

Now recon if one guy wins half of the rounds clearly and even scores a knockdown in both fights (the 2 Matthysse fights), that's a robbery in my book. :deal

 

What people fail to understand about calling the JMM vs Pac 3 a robbery is that it wasn't called a robbery because JMM beat him by an overwhelming number of rounds, but more so because he beat him clearly by several rounds. The key word being CLEARLY.

 

how would you know that when you're watching wrestling before you saw floyd beat the big show?

 

Matthysse and Alexander was the clearest

 

what rounds did jmm beat pac "clearly" aside from round 5?

 

That wasn't a robbery. Some judges appreciate different preformances- Castillo fought a dirty, ugly fight- some judges look down upon that. And of course there was the HBO commentary bull**** bias with that old ****** Lederman's garbage score card. It could have gone either way. But you should really shut the **** up about robberies friend, because Pac got a gift decision against Marquez 3 times.

 

Robbery is an overused term, but yes they were.