Prime Oscar beats Cotto Maidana Alvarez Corrales Castillo He already beat Mosley and was robbed in the rematch and debatably won the first one. Undrained I'd give him a shot against Pacquiao.
Wow, I will never understand boxing fans wanting to rewrite the record book. Ok since you think Oscar got robbed, let's rephrase the question to suit your thinking. Can Oscar go through Floyd's resume without "getting robbed"? Or can Oscar go through Floyd's resume without OFFICIALLY losing? Also Oscar himself said he wouldn't be able to beat Camelot. Yeah, so there's that...
Canelo barely beat Lara and Trout, prime Oscar handles him with ease, he's hyping his money maker, what do you think he'll say no he sucks I'll beat him easily.
Well I think Oscar can beat Maidana, Corrales and possibly Castillo in a close fight. The thing people don't realise about going through the others resume is timing. Even if you think Prime Oscar can beat say Alvarez but can 36 year old Oscar do it, because that's when Floyd fought Alvarez.
I'm one who scored for Quartey, Trinidad, and Mosley both times vs DLH, but I don't see anyone on Mayweather's resume that beats any of these fighters I just named and that includes DLH himself. Oscar DLH goes undefeated against Floyd Mayweather's opposition. A prime DLH would have obliterated the Mosley that Mayweather faced. I think the toughest beat in Mayweather's resume for DLH would have been Canelo Alvarez, but I would pick DLH to beat him and I'm no DLH fan. The question is would Mayweather have beaten the fighters that DLH lost to????? How would Mayweather come out fighting the likes of Quartey, Whitaker, Trinidad, prime Mosley????? I doubt seriously he comes out of that round robin even winning half of those fights. Fact is Mayweather's resume as far as "caliber of opposition" doesn't stack up against DLH's.
Really does 147 38 year old Oscar beat the Pac that 147lb 38 year old Floyd beat. Plus I changed my mind on Corrales I remember how green and chimney Oscar was at the lower weights and how hard a punched Corrales was.