Oscar: "In my Prime I'd School Pacquiao!"

That is why we can not have meaningful debates in ESB anymore!! We are overran by idiots like mamasupra, karceno, spud1, and the bunch.

 

No **** he will. Despite the lacklustre competition at Light Welterweight and Weightweight his performances against Barerra, Marquez, Larios etc have sealed him as an ATG, then his performances at such a high weight for such a small man have only added to that legacy. I wouldn't be surprised if he goes down as the greates Asian fighter of all time and finds his way into people's top 20 P4P lists.

However that doesn't stop him losing H2H against a man who is so much bigger than him, so much technically better etc. Oscar's no chump and he too will go down as an ATG just nowhere near Manny. As a massive Oscar fan I have no problem admitting he won't go down as a greater fighter than Manny.

 

The Trinidad, Mosley and I'd say Hopkins losses will effect him more. Also the relatively early end to his career, he was never as active as I'd have liked him to be after the second Mosley loss.

 

mamasupra = mamanullege = mamaharris

 

I doubt it. He might be remembered as a technically better fight, maybe an all round better fighter, but Mannys resume is too good even though Oscar has Whitaker.

 

I'd actually feel sorry for him if people looked at his resume and didn't hold it in high regard, which is saying a lot because I think Manny is a weasel.